Related
Books have long been a goldmine for movie idea for years , from classics likeOne Flew Over the goose ’s NestandThe Lord of the Ringsto more late works likeAnnihilationandGone Girl .
In recent years , however , there ’s been a deluge of movie adaptations of young adult novel that assay to tap into the teen market as well as solicitation to older audiences . Thanks to the successes ofThe Hunger GamesandTwilight , the trend for YA book - to - moving picture adaptations seems to only have grown strong . Since the popularity of YA novel has yet to cool down down , there ’s still a whole treasure trove of material for studio apartment EXEC to draw from .
However , not everyone can stay in the limelight like Katniss and Harry , even with a wiz - studded cast and big - name director . The stigma around YA picture show — particularly paranormal romances — has n’t helped either . Still , that has n’t cease studio from trying to launch the next big franchise .
This tilt takes into thoughtfulness both critic ’ consensus , audience reactions , and box bureau carrying into action , but it leans more heavily on the latter two . After all , it ’s the popularity of a movie that induce it a collision , even if the brushup are unfavorable , and astral reviews do n’t always save movie from flop at the box place .
There are n’t spoilers for any of the motion picture or books listed , so you could definitely see out the works mentioned and decide whether you agree with the critics or not .
Here are11 YA Movie Adaptations That Flopped ( And 9 Massive smash ) .
Flop: Eragon
Eragoncaptured the hearts and minds of many a teen when it was re - published by Alfred A. Knopf in 2003 , two years after writer Christopher Paolini ’s parent first self - published the book .
While some have criticized it for its similarity toStar WarsandEarthsea , its popularity prompted 20thCentury Fox to free a film adaptation . It even had pretty impressive cast of characters comprising of acclaim actors like Rachel Weisz and Jeremy Irons , while then - rising stars like Ed Speleers and Garret Hedlund rounded out the argumentation - up . However , even these amazing actors could n’t quite make the wooden dialogue work .
The movie did so poorly that initial plan to make it a multi - part franchise were scrapped .
It was even the 10thworst reviewed film of the year onRotten Tomatoes .
Hit: The Hunger Games
Suzanne Collins won numberless award forThe Hunger Gamesand its sequel , so it was only a affair of time before it was picked up for a movie version . Lionsgate and Color Force Colorado - produced the movie , which became a blockbuster and solidified Jennifer Lawrence ’s position in the mainstream limelight . It also helped launch the career of Amandla Stenberg , who has gone on to star inEverything , Everythingand this year’sThe Hate U Give , both of which are also YA Word of God - to - picture show adaptations . Although the movies and books have been criticized for its strong similarities withBattle Royale , that has n’t stop trillion of fan from cheering for the introverted girl from District 12 who becomes a symbolization of rebellion .
Flop: Inkheart
In Cornelia Funke’sInkhearttrilogy , Meggie and her father Mo are capable to bring fiction into the actual world by reading books out loud . The creativity of the premiss and the way the books celebrate the joy of reading material have win Funke legion award in Germany and in the U.S.
The movie adaptation from New Line Cinema seemed promise with a roll that include Helen Mirren , Brenden Fraser , and Andy Serkis . But unlike Mo and Meggie , the movie failed the character of the book to spirit .
It has a critic rating of 38 % on Rotten Tomatoes , and the audience grievance is only marginally better at 45 % .
Inkheartmay be the first book in a trilogy , but the flick adaption does n’t have any sequels on the view .
Hit: Love, Simon
This heart - warming coming - of - years story about a closeted sunny teen first break open onto the panorama in 2015 as the novelSimon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agendaby Becky Albertalli . It accrued many accolades and positive review , eventually prompting 20thCentury Fox toadapt the book into a movie .
The movie has helped make strides for inclusion in Hollywood as the first teen romance from a major studio apartment to focalize on a mirthful adolescent . Plus , away from the significance of focus on a queer teen , it ’s a hearty movie , with a whopping 91 % on Rotten Tomatoes and a good deal of cocksure review .
There ’s a book sequel calledLeah on the Offbeatthat focuses on Leah , so while there are n’t any concrete plans to adapt it , it ’s certainly not an impossible candidate .
Flop: I Am Number Four
I Am Number Fourby Pittacus Lore ( aka James Frey and Jobie Hughes ) spend seven weeks in the top touch of theNew York Timesbestseller list , but the sci - fi novel did n’t do well as a picture .
DreamWorks won the rights and Michael Bay produced the film variation , while teen heartthrob Alex Pettyfer and Dianna Agron star .
Despite the gravid names attached to the production , the moving-picture show have mostly mixed reviews .
The book is the first in a serial of seven record book , so the film could have been a multi - film enfranchisement a la theTwilightseries . However , I Am telephone number Four’sappalling performance meant that any plans for sequels were put to a halt , at least for now .
Hit: The Princess Diaries
Before Anne Hathaway became an award - win household name , she play Mia Thermopolis in the movie adjustment of Meg Cabot ’s novelThe Princess Diaries .
Its paygrade on Rotten Tomatoes sits at 47 % , but the motion picture has produced so many iconic moments that it ’s lodged solidly in pop culture . Plus , with Whitney Houston on board as a producer and Julie Andrews play the Queen of Genovia , the movie impel Hathaway into the public eye . Not bad for a movie debut .
The Princess Diariesis a series of over ten Scripture , but there ’s only two movies to escort . That articulate , there ’s a script forThe Princess Diaries 3 . So who knows , maybe Princess Mia will have a exultant restoration in the future .
Flop: Cirque Du Freak: The Vampire’s Assistant
The Saga of Darren Shanby Darren Shan is a serial of twelve YA horror Good Book that have been translate into 30 oral communication . The moving picture adaptationof the first three volume did n’t relish the same popularity as the source material , though , and it could n’t ride the rising tide of vampire movies introduce byTwilight .
The movie boasts an impressive plaster bandage that includes John C. Reilly , Salma Hayek , Willem Dafoe , Ken Watanabe and a teenaged Josh Hutcherson , all under the focal point of Paul Weitz .
The movie was a massive flop thanks to its feeble portrayal and poor pacing .
Despite there being nine more book in the serial , it ’s secure to say that a pic sequel is n’t happening any meter presently .
Flop: Stormbreaker
The movie adaptation ofStormbreakerby Anthony Horowitz ( released in the U.S. asAlex Rider : Operation Stormbreaker ) was originally intend to be the scratch line of a moving-picture show franchise . The original series comprises of over a 12 books , admit the subsidiary book , but the movie did n’t savor the same level of success .
The level follows a 14 - yr - previous boy who is enrol by the Special Operations Division of MI6 pursue the passing of his uncle who had been a spy , played by Ewan McGregor . The movie even features big names like Andy Serkis , Stephen Fry and Bill Nighy , but finally flopped .
However , it did innovate audiences to new Alex Pettyfer though , who was slate to become the next major teen perfection .
Hit: Twilight
sleep together it or detest it , no list about YA movie adaptation would ever be complete without theTwilightseries by Stephenie Meyer . The first Christian Bible of the serial had mixed reviews and has been criticized for romanticizing toxic relationship , but the criticism did n’t stymie its climb to the top of theNew York Timesbestseller list .
The first movie also receive half-hearted reviews from critics , leave in a military rating of 49 % on Rotten Tomatoes . Its sequels make out even worse , with paygrade ranging from 25 % to 48 % . Still , that did n’t stop fans from flocking to the theatres to witness the romance between Edward and Bella , even when the final book was split into two movie .
In fact , Twilighthad the highest ever opening weekend vulgar for a cinema directed by a fair sex when it was released .
Flop: The Host
TheTwilightseries might have been a major hit among both movie - goers and reader , but Meyer ’s other notable workThe Hostcouldn’t quite live up to those high touchstone . The Hostis determine in a post - revelatory world in which bloodsucking aliens have taken over humanity .
The plot focuses a parasitic stranger who inhabit the body of a human named Melanie , although the motion picture concenter on Melanie ( played by Saoirse Ronan ) instead of the extraterrestrial .
The Holy Scripture became a # 1 New York Times best seller , but the picture was n’t exactly a bunch - pleaser .
While audience were lukewarm about it , critic by and large panned the moving picture for its fallible script , lack of striking tension , and stereotypic use of young adult romance tropes .
