Related
Superhero movies are phenomenally democratic with audiences . Many of them have been quite successful from a fiscal stand . In 2018 alone , Black PantherandAvengers : Infinity Warboth made more than $ 675 million in North America , making them two of the boastful corner authority striking of all fourth dimension . Of of course , there have also been some dud , several of them middling famous , but the ongoing overall popularity of superhero moving-picture show suggests they wo n’t be going aside anytime soon .
What have the critic had to say about them , though ? There ’s a common misconception that critics do n’t like playfulness , escapist movies – that they " desire everything to beCitizen Kane . " That ’s not even remotely genuine , especially in this day and long time , where many of them were raise on Hollywood blockbuster . The stereotype persevere nevertheless . Critics have , on several occasion , overwhelmingly herald film about superheroes . That read , it ’s true they wo n’t hold back if one comes along that is n’t up to sniff .
Using the democratic review aggregate internet site Rotten Tomatoes and its democratic " Tomatometer " as a base , we ’ve compiled this list of the fifteen best - review superhero movies and the fifteen worst - reviewed . You might be surprised by how near - unanimous the vital acclaim for some of these pictures is . A couple of them are within spit length of a gross 100 % . In other cases , you might be offend by what ’s not here . For example , the much - ridiculedJudge Dredd , Barb Wire , andX - Men Origins : Wolverine ? They ’re actually not among the worst - reviewed .
The critic have talk , so let ’s see what they had to say .
Here are the15 Most Rotten ( And 15 Freshest ) Superhero Movies , According To Rotten Tomatoes .
Rotten - The Spirit (14%)
After atomic number 27 - directing the screen adaptation of his dear workSin Citywith Robert Rodriguez , funny book writer / creative person Frank Miller decided to try a solo directing effort . The Spirit , based on the Will Eisner mirthful , give in 2008 . Rodriguez ’s absent was definitely felt .
The confusing game , slow characterization , and emphasis on visual stylus over substance were often cite as defect .
Even an all - star topology cast that included Scarlett Johansson and Samuel L. Jackson could n’t save it . Only 14 % of critics who post reviews ofThe Spiriton Rotten Tomatoes rate it favorably .
Fresh - X-Men: Days of Future Past (90%)
Adapting the watershed lifelike novelX - Men : Days of Future Pastfor the screen was a toughened job . Maintaining the film series ' persistence required altering some aspects of the story , which is a fan favorite . Aside from the matter of whether the variety would go , there was also the inquiry of whether fan would revolt .
Everything work out all right in this font . X - Menfans sanction of the movie , as did critics , who helped it achieve a " certified sweet " grievance of 90 % . They make out the intricate secret plan . In fact , Days of Future Pasthas the good Tomatometer rating of the full dealership .
Rotten - Underdog (14%)
Underdogwas an attempt to take an former cartoon show about a superhero dog and make it relevant for today ’s young audiences .
Rather than hand - draw living , the movie utilize live thespian and CGI hot dog . Jason Lee and Amy Adams provide the voices of Underdog and his pal Polly . Yes , these andiron can talk . That somewhat creepy-crawly tone was noted in many reviews , as were the subpar special personal effects .
Although Underdog is a Disney movie , it was fairly low - budget for the studio apartment , and it picture .
Being aimed forthright at minor eight and under also prevent the film from going above 14 % on Rotten Tomatoes .
Fresh - Captain America: Civil War (91%)
By the clip ofCaptain America : Civil War , Marvel had firmly instal a consistent success rate with its superhero movies . This motion picture was unlike , though , in that it assembled a whole bunch of beloved characters and then had them fight each other . break everyone their due and avoiding a muddled pile - up was n’t decease to be easy .
Critics were impressed byCivil War ’s ability to deplume that off , along with its thematic depth and strong word-painting . They deemed it a skillful , matured superhero film . The end result was an impressive 91 % blessing military rank .
Rotten - Blankman (13%)
Blankmanis a 1994 superhero drollery star Damon Wayans as a simpleton who decides to diddle homemade superhero . fashion a costume out of his nanna ’s sometime pelage , he dubs himself Blankman and sic out to bring down a local pack political boss .
The movie was a boxwood bureau flop , as well as a critical punching bag .
The consensus was that the story ’s attempts to spoof superhero conventions just were n’t funny , and they often slip into tired slapstick . In the conclusion , only two critics on Rotten Tomatoes had nice things to say , lead to a dismal 13 % sexual conquest .
Fresh - Guardians of the Galaxy (91%)
Writer / film director James Gunn had a enceinte challenge ahead of him when he signed on to make Marvel’sGuardians of the Galaxy . The characters had a cult succeed , but were virtually nameless by the world-wide public . Gunn ’s mission was to demonstrate them as viable heroes within the Marvel Cinematic Universe .
uncalled-for to say , he accomplished that delegation magnificently . critic were affect by howGuardiansworked within the MCU while still possessing its own identity , completely disjoined from that . The quirky humor also won their party favour . Gunn and his stars find themselves staring at a prima 91 % evaluation .
Rotten - The Crow: City of Angels (12%)
Despite the tragedy beleaguer it , The Crowwent on to become a solid box situation strike . The enfranchisement probably should have stopped there , give that star Brandon Lee perished in a tragical on - set stroke . Hollywood being what it is , a series of uninspired sequels keep up .
The Crow : City of Angelssubstituted Vincent Perez for Lee . critic were quick to point out that he lacked his late predecessor ’s natural on - screen charisma .
Director Tim Pope neglect to recapture the dark , forbidding smell that gave the original its power .
City of Angelslimped away with just 12 % of critic aim their pollex up .
Fresh - The Avengers (92%)
It probably would n’t be an exaggeration to say thatMarvel ’s The Avengerswas one of the most - anticipate movies ever when it was released in 2012 . Never before had so many bountiful - name superheroes been onscreen together at the same time . The danger was in unsatisfying masses , give that the prospect were so eminent .
This was a face where fans and critics were in total agreement . review repeatedly point out that the film raise Marvel ’s cinematic plot considerably , paying off the buildup that took place over several previous moving picture and setting up new things that look promise .
The Avengersended up assembling enough raves to land an impressive 92 % approval rating .
Rotten - Steel (12%)
On the Thomas Nelson Page , Steel is a very large , hulking grapheme . There were n’t many actors who were physically right-hand for the part , so the filmmakers look to the universe of sports instead . basketball game pro Shaquille O’Neal , who stands seven metrical foot tall , took on the job of portraying the DC superhero .
leave that he ’s not an thespian by trade , it ’s no surprisal critics pointed out that Steel featured some rather poor act from Shaq .
They were n’t impressed with the developing story , either . The silly looking of the principal character ’s costume was also a sticking point . Because of these issues , Steelcarries an embarrassingly small 12 % rating .
Fresh - Wonder Woman (92%)
It ’s evenhandedly unwashed cognition among movie buff that the DCEU has struggled with its cinematic output , especially when equate to the continual winner of Marvel . In spite of that , the party dead knocked one out of the park withWonder Woman . Director Patty Jenkins and whiz Gal Gadot made a hall - of - fame superhero moving picture .
Their endeavour were rewarded with a 92 % account on the Tomatometer . critic praised the portrayal of Wonder Woman , who is strong , smart , and ego - reliant . Gadot ’s operation similarly earn huzzahs , as did the piquant story and its tremendous distaff authorization message .
