Related
Movie adaptations of untried adult ( or YA ) novel have been around for a long time , most notably with theHarry Potterfranchise , but it was the waiver ofTwilightin 2008 that truly kicked off a fury . The $ 37 million production earn $ 192 million in North America and an additional $ 200 million worldwide .
Hollywood studios looked at those numbers , catch the devotion of the fan base , and visualize that other YA adaption could work just as well . on the spur of the moment , any even remotely popular book chance some producer looking to buy its screen door rights .
The truth is that almost none of these version have been as financially successful asHarry PotterorTwilight . While some have been hits , many have been outright bomb calorimeter . The spirit level of timbre has been very mixed , as well . A number of them were warmly receive by the land ’s pic critics , as evidenced by their high score on Rotten Tomatoes . Others were met with derision for their want of quality or unsuccessful person to interpret what made the root material pop .
We ’ve scoured Rotten Tomatoes to retrieve the YA adaptations that have been rated most " rotten " and the one rated most " fresh . " In each face , we ’ll tell you what the vital consensus was , as well as which elements were most commonly single out for kudos or scorn . Some of these scores are imposingly high , others embarrassingly down in the mouth . Either direction , the critics have spoken , so let ’s see what they had to say .
Here are the15 Most Rotten ( And 15 Freshest ) YA Adaptations , harmonise To Rotten Tomatoes .
Rotten - The Giver (35%)
Not even the star power of Jeff Bridges , Meryl Streep , and Taylor Swift could saveThe Giver , an adaptation of Lois Lowry ’s Newbery Medal - bring home the bacon novel that has become a common middle school meter reading assignment .
The narration is about a high society with no pain in the neck or hurt , and a boy who is mentored in the ways of the " tangible " world by an older man .
Critics irresistibly agree that the movie does n’t delve deep enough into the complex theme that make the book a continual favorite . They deem it too shallow , resulting in a less - then - stellar 35 % approval rating .
Fresh - The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants (77%)
A charming pair of blue denim is at the substance ofThe Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants , establish on the first in a series of novels by Ann Brashares . Four female ally share those jeans as they pilot various personal quandary .
The film was lauded for its affecting portrayal of friendship .
run actresses Blake Lively , Alexis Bledel , America Ferrera , and Amber Tamblyn got great follow-up , not just for their individual performances , but also for the authentic group dynamic they create together .
The end result was a fresh RT score of 77 % and a friendly relationship that has endure until today .
Rotten - If I Stay (35%)
A fortune of adolescents who register Gayle Foreman’sIf I Stayare earnestly into its deep tale . In the film variation , Chloe Grace Moretz plays Mia Hall , a missy who ends up in a coma after a car accident . An out - of - body experience follows , during which she has to make up one’s mind whether to return to lifespan or move on to the afterworld . Obviously , it ’s a tearjerker .
The only job is that critics wanted to yell for all the wrong reason . They felt the potentially meaningful tale was handled in a fashion that was more manipulative and corny than touching . Only 35 % of them conceive the movie was worth seeing .
Fresh - Holes (78%)
base on the Louis Sachar book , Holesgave Shia LaBeouf an early big screen role . He plays Stanely Yelnats , a teen male child transmit to a custody camp where he ’s forced to grasp holes . Jon Voight plays the pettish inner circle director and Sigourney Weaver is the even fractious warden .
recap forHoleswere largely positively charged , leading to a 78 % at Rotten Tomatoes .
The movie pull in accolades for telling its story with word and not speak down to the unseasoned target audience .
LaBeouf was also singled out as a rising headliner for his piece of work as Stanley .
Rotten - I Am Number Four (32%)
I Am Number Foursure sound like it should have worked . Pittcus Lore ’s science - fable tale about an extra - terrestrial name John ( Alex Pettyfur ) hiding on Earth from the foe that ’s trying to winnow out him has it all – activity , adventure , humor , and romance . Dianna Agron fulfills that last element as John ’s making love pursuit .
This is one of those cases where what seemed fresh on the page feel cliched onscreen . Reviews pointed to a pervasive feeling of familiarity inI Am Number Four .
Critics were n’t bowl over by Pettyfur ’s bland functioning either , leading to a score of 32 % .
Fresh - The Miseducation of Cameron Post (78%)
The novel movie on this lean isThe Miseducation of Cameron Post , adapted from the book by Emily Danforth . Chloe Grace Moretz plays the claim character , a teenaged girl whose parents force her to attend a " changeover center " after they come to believe she might be homophile .
Reviews for the film point out that it handle the LGBT - related capable matter with adequate parts humor and insight .
Moretz is also getting kudos for her compassionate performance .
As of this writing , The Miseducation of Cameron Postis just opening and has an 78 % score . That may vary slightly as more review come in .
Rotten - Insurgent (29%)
TheDivergentfranchise was supposed to be a very grown deal , especially with its attractive unseasoned plaster bandage that include Shailene Woodley , Theo James , and Miles Teller .
Veronica Roth ’s series did n’t translate well to the screen , though , with all three entry garnering weak reviews .
The 2d chapter , Insurgent , land right in the midsection , scoring a 29 % . Reviews justifiedly pointed out that YA adaptations about teen contend wickedness in a dystopian future were played out by 2015 . This flick simply did n’t have new ideas to bring to the table . Not even the charismatic lead could salve it .
Fresh - The Spiderwick Chronicles (80%)
InThe Spiderwick Chronicles , twin boys and their baby discover some bizarre occurrent taking place at the bedraggled residence their family moves into . When an US Army of eldritch creatures assault the home in search of an ancient book , the kids must fight them off .
Tony DiTerlizzi and Holly Black ’s book series number to the screenland in striking manner , earning a solid 80 % approval rating from the country ’s critics .
Reviewers hump the ocular expressive style of the film , in addition to the overall sensation of imagination .
Star Freddie Highmore was celebrated for his three-fold carrying out as the twins .
Rotten - The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement (25%)
The Princess Diaries 2 : Royal Engagementis the continuation to the surprise 2001 hit .
barrack by the Meg Cabot YA series – but not based on any special installment – it follows the journey of Mia Thermopolis ( Anne Hathaway ) as she comes to price with the fact that an ordered matrimony has been set up for her .
While the originalPrincess Diariesreceived mixed reviews at serious , this follow - up stalled out at 25 % . A frequent chorus was that Mia ’s story had essentially been told the first time around , leave the sequel to rehash many of the same musical theme and jokes .
Fresh - The Fault in Our Stars (80%)
John Green did something bold when he wroteThe Fault in Our Stars . He told a story about teenager with genus Cancer in a way that was n’t depressing . There was even a bar of humor in it .
The film version , starring Shailene Woodley and Ansel Elgort , manage to get out off the same feat , direct it to an 80 % valuation .
decisive consensus was that Josh Boone ’s version avoided all the well-fixed " disease picture show " tropes , bring in its emotions honestly .
The lead actors got mountain of love for their empathic portrayals of the primary characters , whose dear transcends their respective illness .
