Casting can make or break off   any moving picture , but the stake are even high when it amount to the superhero genre . Could you imagine , for example , if Christopher Nolan’sThe Dark Knighthad asterisk   Jared Leto in place of Heath Ledger ?

Now attempt to visualize theX - Menmovies with anyone other than Hugh Jackman in the role of Wolverine . It might be difficult to imagine but it very nearly chance . And on more than one juncture too .

Back in 1990 , when Stan Lee was in discussion anX - Menmovie that would have been orchestrate by Kathryn Bigelow with Carolco Pictures , Bob Hoskins was the frontrunner to land the part of Logan .

Dark X-Men in Marvel Comics' Age of Apocalypse

Fast - forward a few years to Bryan Singer’sX - Menmovie , and Russell Crowe was in the skeleton for the part . He would ultimately move around it down , citing an eagerness to do something less action mechanism - orient afterGladiatorbut recommended his friend , Jackman , for the role .

However ,   despite delivering an impressing audition ,   the studio opted for Dougray Scott over the little - known Australian . What they never report for was the fact that Scott was already in product onMission : unacceptable 2 .

Handpicked by Tom Cruise to play the   movie ’s villain , mount delays on the John Woo - aim subsequence at long last forced Fox and Singer to trench Scott at the last minute and hire Jackman in his place .

61 Years Later, Marvel Introduces the X-Men’s Original Magneto, And They’re Unbelievably Dark copia

It proved to be a masterstroke and   an example of stark , if middling causeless , retch . There are other examples of this throughout theX - Menmovie universe .

It ’s not always work out quite so well ,   however , with deal of gifted and not - so - talented stars appearing out - of - sorts and out - of - spot throughout the franchise .

With that said , here are the18 Casting decision That Hurt TheX - MenMovies ( And 17 That carry through Them ) .

Comic book art: 1990s X-Men, with Cyclops front and center, surrounded by characters including Storm, Gambit, and more.

Hurt: Vinnie Jones as the Juggernaut

As far as movie tough guys go , Vinnie Jones sure looks the part .   This is n’t   by chance event , either . Jones had a unnerving report as a soccer star from his days in the Premier League and was able to parlay some of that same fearsome charm into a   movie career .

Starting withLock , Stock and Two Smoking Barrels , and continue with plastic film likeSwordfish , Jones established a report for toy character whose action spoke louder than words .

However , cast Jones as   Juggernaut   and   giving him a lot of lines , including one referencing an internet meme , just did n’t look as respectable on screen .

X-Men Apocalypse poster

take heed the distressingly wooden Jones say the words " I ’m the Jagganath , b***h "   still transport a tremor down the back of any ego - respecting buff .

Saved: Ian McKellan as Magneto

Though the likes of Christopher Lee and   Terence Stamp were linked with the role during pre - yield on 2000’sX - human beings , Ian   McKellen   ended up bagging the part having worked with director Bryan Singer on his previous effort , Apt Pupil .

He played a war criminal enshroud out in American suburbia in that   movie in a use that was   good practice for the duality of iconic Marvel scoundrel -   charming and courteous one second , unpleasant and strong-growing the next .

Having a Shakespearian worker also gave this Magneto a suitably theatrical feel , while   McKellen ’s   on - screen chemistry with Patrick Stewart has been fundamental to the success of the enfranchisement .

Vinnie Jones Juggernaut

Hurt: Rebecca Romijn as Mystique

Rebecca   Romijn   was already well established as a model and fame in her own correctly prior to her cast in Bryan Singer ’s firstX - Menmovie .

It represented her first major movie office , though it was one that proved an unwelcome misdirection .

jade a " costume " that comprise of little more than some blue makeup and some strategically placed prosthetics , this Mystique may have been an effectual silent assassin , but her lack of line or anything in the style of character development left Romijn serving as picayune more than eye candy .

Sir Ian McKellen as Magneto in X Men Days of Future Past

This   is a shame , as   Romijn   would later prove herself a up to actress with office on show likeUgly Betty .

Saved: Patrick Stewart as Professor X

As the   yin   to Ian   McKellen ’s   yang inX - Men , Patrick Stewart ’s suitability for the theatrical role of Professor Xavier was n’t just down to his chemistry with the   Magneto   doer . It felt like he was turn out to act as the part .

Not only   does he   hold a striking resemblance to the Professor Xavier of the Marvel comics , but he also conveys the same kind of academic dignity as the fibre .

This is something that was no doubt helped by his Hellenic training as an player .

Rebecca Romijn as Mystique

The fact that he ’d already served with distinction as Captain Jean - Luc Picard onStar Trek : The Next Generationalso show his versatility and range with   the sort of " inventive " stuff that some actors would head off .

Hurt: Shawn Ashmore as Iceman

The depiction of Iceman in the original trilogy ofX - Menmovies must surely rank among the most unsatisfying of the total franchise , for the most part because he is n’t given a whole lot to do .

Injecting the part with a footling attitude or some sense of fun might have helped remedy   this ,   but worker Shawn Ashmore mostly played it safe .

Deployed in a secondary role , Ashmore ’s Iceman is painfully vanilla , with the doer struggling to asseverate himself on the CRT screen as small more than an occasional dearest interest .

Patrick Stewart as Professor X

Ashmore has   speak of a willingness to repay to the persona follow the intriguing comic book storyline that saw Iceman follow out as gay . regrettably , this looks likely to pass .

Saved: Hugh Jackman as Wolverine

It ’s unmanageable to conceive of anyone other than Hugh Jackman as Wolverine .   This is how secure he ’s been in the role across a 17 - year trance playing the Marvel icon .

As arguably one of the most popular and therefore   pressurized comic Holy Scripture   character , Jackman has shone during the respectable , bad , and   ugly piece of theX - Menmovie franchise .

see and sounding the part is no fluke , either . Jackman ’s dieting and fitness regime for the role is the stuff of legend and imbues his performance with a physicality befitting of a civilize , military " weapon system " of a human beings , fit with adamantium claw et al .

Iceman Rogue Cut

Jackman ’s theatrical background also ensures that he nails the aroused intensity of Logan metre and time again .

Hurt: Oscar Isaac as Apocalypse

When the first images of Oscar Isaac as Apocalypse surfaced online , fans were far from happy .

After yr waiting for one of theX - Menuniverse ’s most feared villains to arrive on the boastful screen , it face like they were getting something more commonly get hold in your standard installment ofMightyMorphin’Power Rangers .

Some cracking post - production workplace might have improved his   visual aspect ,   but it did little to enhance Isaac ’s surprisingly stilted performance .

Hugh Jackman as Wolverine

Revelation of Saint John the Divine was supposed to be the most feared of all theX - Menvillains but , physically speaking , Isaac is simply too small .

Saved: Ryan Reynolds as Deadpool

10 - Men Origins : Wolverineis one unholy mess of a movie . Not even the bearing of Hugh Jackman opposite the equally excellent   Liev   Schreiber   can salvage legal proceeding .

This is a shame , because there are moment where the   moving picture is really enjoyable .   Some of them take Ryan Reynolds ' Wade Wilson , who compact enough activity and wisecracks into one short scenery early in the picture show to highlight why aDeadpoolmovie could puzzle out .

It may have taken a few more years of negotiations , some stellar scripts , and a leak screenland test , but the reality is there would be noDeadpoolmovies without   this guy rope and the decision to cast Reynolds in the first place .

X-Men: Apocalypse post credits scene

Hurt: Nicholas Hoult as Beast

Nicholas Hoult is a more than able actor and someone   who can become his bridge player to a variety of literary genre with aplomb . He ’s just not Hank McCoy .

Sure , he ’s got the geeky , scientist aspect of the fictitious character down , but McCoy always had a little more punch to him than the English actor contribute , both physically and in terminus of on - blind personality .

This is   why someone like Kelsey   Grammer   was arguably better suit to the part .

X Men Origins Wolverine Mouthless Deadpool

Finding a young actor that might have fit that criteria might have been a challenge , but Hoult just does n’t have the necessary virtuoso quality for what is an crucial role .

Saved: Halle Berry as Storm

Angela Bassett may have been the first selection for the use of   Storm ,   but Halle Berry proved to be an inhale choice as   theX - Menheroine .

Despite a twine of critically - acclaimed performances in lesser production , major mainstream success had eluded Berry until then .

This changed with disco biscuit - gentleman ,   where   Berry pull off the role of tempest to perfection despite being reprehensively underused .

Nicholas Hoult as Beast in X-Men

With a   magnetised onscreen comportment   and interchangeable looks to Storm , her by choice subdued delivery and general air of adulthood and dignity tote up something a little different to the ten - Men mix .

Should she have got more screenland metre and her own plot ?   emphatically , but   she was still effective .

X-Men Storm Wolverine

Movies

X-Men