Related
In theHarry Potteruniverse , there are sight of thing that boggle our brains about Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald on their own . The two brilliant but blemished characters are tie down to have their idiosyncrasies , but some facts about the superstar just do n’t make any sense . For example , why does Grindelwald have an English stress when he ’s bonk to have attend Durmstrang Academy rather than Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry ? Between legion timeline mix - ups , the fact that Dumbledore is portrayed as a Defense Against the Dark Arts instructor in theFantastic Beastfilms and several other inconsistencies , there ’s enough confusion regarding one or the other powerful wizard as is .
Put the two together , however , and their family relationship is even more mind - boggling . While rooter generally bonk the backstory between the two champion since it not only touch to Dumbledore ’s preference , which is never fully cover in the books as it should have been but also demonstrates how even the brightest and most gifted wizards persist highly flawed human beings who make mistakes , too many problems and inconsistencies subsist throughout their histories . Not only were too many things pulled out of the blueness to at random bestow striking panache to the pic , all snuff it against what we live from the originalHarry Potterbook series , but many fact about the distich violate the Christian Bible of author J.K. Rowling herself .
From that uncanny oath to the Mirror of Erised ’s revelation inFantastic animal : The Crimes of Grindelwald , here are25 Things That Make No Sense About Dumbledore And Grindelwald ’s Relationship .
No Blood Pact Was Mentioned In The Original Series
When fans heard about the mysterious Blood Pact , most felt nothing but disarray . Why was this special wizard pinky promise never mentioned at all in the Harry Potter books ? Sure , we get to get word about new spells , beast and sorcerer culture all of the time in the new film , but we ’ve been introduced to the Unbreakable Vow before , so this seems unneeded . Why create this new swearing ?
It would make more sense to call this an Unbreakable Vow , which would link it with the repose of the series . It also feel shadier than an Unbreakable Vow since it involves blood , so why not use that for Snape ’s hope instead ?
Dumbledore And Grindelwald Fought Before
Whatever the abstract thought behind using a antecedently unmentioned Blood Pact , it does n’t make gumption that Dumbledore and Grindelwald made one since they had an incredibly wild and irresponsible Duel that resulted in the loss of Dumbledore ’s sister Ariana before they parted way . Given that the Duel was the last time they saw each other , when on Earth did they make this treaty that would have had to come about after the Duel ?
It ’s super improbable that they would pause and rationally make this treaty while Ariana ’s exanimate form lay in the debris of their terrible fight , and since they have n’t seen her since , they could n’t have made this treaty .
Their Closeness Was Barely Alluded To In The Films
There ’s been a big focus on the secretiveness between Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald in the Harry Potter book , and it ’s helped to explain everything from how Dumbledore himself has changed and grown to how he became the person to defeat the most dastardly wizard who lived before Voldemort .
So why do we see quite a routine of Grindelwald and Dumbledore without this context in the movie ? What small hints we receive are equivocal at good , with sports fan job on the nature of their genuine family relationship to the point where J.K. Rowling had to step in and explicate , even though she ’s already stated that there was once love between the men .
Dumbledore Was On Board For World Domination
Dumbledore was totally sweep up in Grindelwald ’s languid eyes , gleeful expression … and design for world supremacy . Many fans think that you need a pair of yoga trouser for a reach like that .
Dumbledore was famous for being a bit of an noetic snot , it ’s reliable , but that ’s a huge stride from being a madman . He reveals to Harry that he was simply catch up in the genius ’s personal magnetism and intellectual , and for a young wizard who resent let to use his unequaled giving to care for his baby , romancing someone new and interesting makes sense . Hatching a muggle elimination scheme with him does n’t .
Dumbledore Was Attracted To Grindelwald’s Dislike
We get that Dumbledore thought that Grindelwald was languorous because of his curly blonde hair , his understanding , and even his magical ability which rivaled his own . Albus in all probability seldom experienced meeting wizard at his own tier . It was probably exciting to meet someone like Gellert , especially when he was bitterly stuck in Godric ’s Hollow as a sitter .
But we have a concentrated prison term seeing how he could have been pull in to the dislike that Grindelwald exhibited toward muggles . It ’s one thing for opposite to attract , but if one of those people has an intense dislike towards a group of people , it seems like it should impregnate revulsion alternatively of fascination .
The Mirror Of Erised Doesn’t Show Flashbacks
There are a few issues with the Mirror of Erised in The Crimes of Grindelwald . One gross effect is the fact that it seems to be used more as a flashback gadget rather than a representation of what the soul desires most . It ’s not a Pensieve , after all .
While it nominate sense that one might desire their past tense , the Mirror scoot from past to present , illustrating a past memory prior to settling on the current faces of Dumbledore and Grindelwald , which is what it should have simply shown in the first position . This felt like a sloppy mode of explaining the pact . Why would Dumbledore require that as his cryptic desire ?
Dumbledore Would Never Make A Blood Oath
While we ’re still hazy on the nature of just what a Blood Pact means to genius , as we put forward earlier , they seem like pretty dark magic . We might expect blue wizards to utilize the sort of magic that requires the draining of blood , but not those who sign to the index of good . It ’s only dark wizards ( and double agent ) whom we ’ve seen make Unbreakable vow , after all .
Dumbledore does n’t seem like the kind of somebody who ’d make such a promise . Even so , we do learn that we do n’t know Albus nearly as well as we think we did , which is one of the points of the serial .
Rowling Said Dumbledore Saw His Family Reunited In The Mirror
What was the breaker point in including the Mirror of Erised inFantastic animal : The Crimes of Grindelwaldwhen it introduced new inconsistency ? Dumbledore once tell Harry Potter that he see some thick woollen socks in the Mirror of Erised , and as alluring as those strait , J.K. Rowlingadmitted that he really saw " his family animated , whole , and glad – Ariana , Percival , and Kendra all retort to him , and Aberforth reconciled to him . "
He certainly did n’t see Gellert Grindelwald or evidence of their Blood Pact , as we see in the movie . As fans have manoeuver out , our desire deepen as we grow and age , so it might make sense on that level .
The Blood Pact Cheapens The Meaning Behind Their Relationship
make love that Dumbledore is merry and that he once bang Grindelwald deep , fans were root for some representation in the picture . By change his reluctance to act against Grindelwald as something inaction due to his feelings to an actual magical bandaging by a weird Blood Pact , not only was the nature of their family relationship muddied , but its very meaning was cheapened .
This was the double-dyed opportunity to include a cheery pair in a series that by artificial means has a million character without delegacy , and it was a dashing hopes for so many fans . Hopefully , it will be addressed in a powerful second afterwards in theFantastic Beastsfilms .
Grindelwald Knows Dumbledore Has A Brother When Albus Doesn’t Seem To Know
Many fans are speculating that there ’s much more to the story than Credence Barebone ’s real identity as Aurelius Dumbledore . It sure enough sound like a prevarication Grindelwald could concoct , but what makes it most frail is that Albus himself does n’t seem to make love his own brother exists .
We ’ve never heard of Aurelius Dumbledore , despite Rita Skeeter ’s dig , and if Albus knew of a long fall behind chum , he ’d certainly be on that knowledge like , well , himself on lemon drops , look for out his crony and attempting to tie in with his family , peculiarly after lose Ariana . If he does make love and just does n’t care , that ’s out of character for the maven .
