Outlander
Outlanderis one of the big shows on boob tube . The romantic narrative , the beautiful Scottish Highlands as the backcloth , with the eighteenth - century being the primary setting makes it one of the most breathtaking and challenging shows on right now . There are all of the add action sequence and the passion between the two protagonists that draws in both male and distaff viewers from all over the public .
But the accuracy of the thing is , the unbelievable popularity of the show would have never happened if they had n’t made the right cast choices with the majority of their case . Luckily for the squad behindOutlander , they did a great job … for most of the characters . Sometimes , though , there were either mistakes made in casting or it was simply just too hard for the fans to fancy sure player in the character of certain characters .
Either way , it has become extravagantly decipherable that proper molding in any television show - specially one that was oblige to become a cultural phenomenon - can make or break it . With that in head , we have broken down the member of theOutlandercast who hurt the show more than helped it , as well as the ace who made it into the sentience it has become .
Here are the7 Casting decision That HurtOutlander(And 13 That Saved It ) .
Saved It: Duncan Lacroix As Murtagh
A rightful surprisal was seeing the television version of Murtagh ’s character , mostly because in the books , he was not nigh as adored as his tv set vis-a-vis . Not to mention , that he get together his fate at the Battle of Culloden , while our Murtagh onscreen lived through the infamous battle .
Lacroix ’s performance give much more depth and complexity to his character , make him a skinny immediate sports fan favorite . The evolution of his fictional character thanks to the actor ’s dedication to the office and true natural endowment in bringing a whole new side to Murtagh is probably a big ground why he live the conflict on the show , which made fans everywhere rejoice .
Hurt It: Sophie Skelton As Bree
In the books , Brianna Randall , who is Jamie and Claire ’s daughter , was described a bit other than than the actress who now plays Bree onscreen .
She is delineate as search much like her father , with her ruby hair and sharp features , which to be fair , Skelton does have both of those descriptors . But she is not roughly six - foot tall , like was described in the book and is pretermit other feature article that were mentioned that lover immediately noticed .
fortunately , though fans of the serial publication were reluctant to initially take Sophie Skelton as Bree , she has acquire audiences over with her performance . It just took some prison term .
Saved It: Sam Heughan As Jamie Fraser
When Diana Gabaldon , writer of theOutlanderbooks , first heard they were study Scottish actor , Sam Heughan , for the function of Jamie Fraser , she was unsure if he was the right fit . Mostly because he was nearly too pretty .
But once she saw his audition , she eff he was it and agree with the producers . And boy , were they all right . He has become so much more than the Scottish hunk who loves Claire with everything he has . He gives each and every functioning his all and makes you finger every emotion Jamie is pouring out through his very pores .
Hurt It: Alison Pargeter As Margaret
This likely has more to do with the type itself , rather than the actress , but watching Alison Pargeter ’s public presentation as Margaret Campbell was in a word , upsetting .
Sure , that was partially the point . But seeing a woman with clearly dealing issues from her genial illness be process so negatively by her own brother , as well as other " important " masses , and used as a psychic of sorts was disheartening . It was a tough character to portray , and she obviously did a okay job with the material , but it was not one of the best portrayals of mental illness on a serial publication .
Saved It: Lotte Verbeek As Geillis Duncan
Geillis Duncan was Claire ’s friend - eventually bend enemy - throughout the first three season ofOutlander . She , too , was a time - traveller , Claire came to find out . And though Geillis had some issues , she was a friend to Claire for a time .
Lotte Verbeek was the actress to bring Geillis to life on the Starz series , and she did so effortlessly . Each of her creative option for the type meshed well with who the eccentric was to her core . Once Geillis went full - villain mode in season 3 , Verbeek went full gas and brought out every conjuring trick in the ledger . It was a stunning execution .
Saved It: Andrew Gower As Bonnie Prince Charlie
Prince Charles led the Jacobite Rebellion in eighteenth - century Scotland and inevitably failed in his mission to take the crown . Outlanderneeded to find the unadulterated role player to act the Bonnie Prince , and they found him in none other than Andrew Gower .
Gower showed off his acting chop as the Prince and emulate his perquisite , wealth , and flamboyancy in every effort and every word . It was , quite frankly , a blame disgrace when his purpose was over by the beginning of time of year 3 because he was just so fun to find out . But much like the real Prince Charlie , the character ’s meter in Scotland was over , and it was time for everyone else to move on , too .
Hurt It: César Domboy As (Older) Fergus
Fergus was a darling lineament from time of year 2 ofOutlander . He , at the fourth dimension , was the little male child Jamie and Claire occupy under their wing while living in France , and eventually brought back with them to Scotland .
Everyone loved untested Fergus , so it stands to reason that it would be hard for a lot of fans to consent an older version of the character played by anyone else other than the original actor . That is what César Domboy was faced with when accepting the role , and it definitely took a while for fan to be on card with the old version of the character .
Now , though , fans seem to have warmed to him , since he still feed a great carrying out . But it unquestionably was n’t overnight .
Saved It: Tobias Menzies As Frank Randall/Blackjack Randall
Tobias Menzies took on a magniloquent order when he was throw away as both Frank Randall and his ancestor , Blackjack Randall , in the score Starz series .
play two vastly different roles on the same show had to have been a mind - warp for Menzies . But he was able to play both the impeccant bystander of Frank Randall , Claire ’s first husband , and the notoriously malevolent Blackjack Randall , Claire and Jamie ’s sworn enemy with sang-froid and unrivaled intensity .
The sheer gift it must take to take on either theatrical role is stupefying , and Menzies certainly gave it his all with blood , sweat , and tears in every installment . Literally .
Hurt It: Ed Speleers As Stephen Bonnet
Ed Speleers had a lot decease up against him when he take away on the role of Stephen Bonnet . Bonnet is , of course of action , the plagiarizer who terrorized both Jamie and Claire when he hook them - after they had saved him for a terrible destiny . But he also terrorized their girl , Bree , when he assaulted her .
Everyone was bound to detest him just because his lineament was so queasy , but the other problem was he was following a grand villainous performance by Tobias Menzies as Blackjack Randall . No matter how much everyone hated Randall , we could n’t help oneself but be enthralled whenever he was on our screen .
Saved It: Stephen Walters As Angus
Angus in the books is a far cry from the Angus we see on the show . For one , he is not nearly as large or covered in hair as trace in the books . And he ’s also not a gruff man who carry out vicious penalization in the Great Hall .
On the show , he is one of Dougal ’s gentleman who makes hilarious quips and likes to drink . When his role expanded on the series , many fans adore Walters ' interpretation of the character and he became a rooter - favorite . Which is why when he met his goal in season 2 , it was in truth heartbreaking .
