It sounds likeaSupergirlmovie may eventually be happening- and we hump just the actress to play her in the DCEU . Well , we knowninewho could handle the role , depending on what kind of a Supergirl narration WB is front to tell .

With a faithful take on Supergirl already airing on The CW , it ’s possible , and probably good for the studio apartment to try something unlike . A younger Kara struggling to interpret her new life , perhaps , or an older Superwoman who can stand asan equal to Henry Cavill ’s Superman .

Heck , why not scrap the " cousin " relationship and just let on Kara to be the last Kryptonian not trying to defeat Clark Kent ?

How Rachel Zegler’s

We bang thatZack Snyder had a architectural plan for Supergirlin his magnanimous movie universe , apparently unrelated to the interpretation of Kara inMan of Steel ’s prequel comic . We would n’t depend that his visual modality will be the one that WB call for , but that only get it harder to guess what actress a Supergirl movie will need , not easier .

In the interest of not only suggesting actresses we could see playing Supergirl , but preparing devotee for what the cast might say about the overall movie ’s direction , we ’re running down our top competitor .

9. Imogen Poots

The character of movie WB will desire to make will inform the cast of Supergirl more than any other broker , so for our first selection , we ’re last with an actress various enough to easy rive off the challenge . Imogen Poots has demonstrated smart , heart , emotion , and a signified of humor throughout her career on film and idiot box ( most recognizable to casual moviegoers for her roles inGreen Room , That Awkward Moment , andNeed For speeding ) .

Her star is still on the rise among her peers , and may abuse into the realm of funny book of account version once the goggle box version ofY : The Last Manarrives ( act Yorick ’s older sister , Hero ) . As an actress who has chosen one interesting project after another , Imogen Poots stepping into the office of Kara Zor - El would n’t just be meet , but a great preindication that the film itself take for promise .

8. Margaret Qualley

The other main question facing a Supergirl on film is how snug it will keep to the telly version currently airing . get into that the filmmaker will want to take Kara in a different centering - perhaps one exploring the fear , closing off , and trauma Kara has to endure upon wake up on Earth - an actress like Margaret Qualley is a bullseye . Because it is n’t well-fixed being dangerous , wild , devastated , and afraid , all while remain inherently likeable . But that ’s something Supergirl and Qualley have achieved in both their past tense .

Lest any fans interest that we ’re pitching a dark , or psychological thriller translation of Supergirl , Kara still ends up as a hero . But being prove on Krypton gives Kara an " otherworldly " nature Clark never faced , Qualley ’s training as a ballet dancer and style framework before performing will give her a head kickoff . And with the range she ’s point in the alive - action adaptation ofDeath Note , Shane Black’sThe Nice Guys , or on HBO’sThe Leftovers , we hope she could do Kara Zor - El justice .

7. Jessica Rothe

If the critical receipt ofBatman v SupermanandSuicide Squad(not the box place ) has convinced the studio apartment that quest for a whimsical , more lighthearted discussion of Supergirl is good , they may not care about the movie falling too closely to the TV show . Which signify that the doorway would be undefendable to another actress slue from the same cloth as Melissa Benoist - that ’s Jessica Rothe , who fans may have already seen obliterate multiple times inHappy Death Day .

Others may know her from the MTV seriesMary + Jane , which affirm her knack for smaller - scale of measurement comedy in unorthodox berth ( and the same buy the farm forDeath Day ) . Again , we ca n’t say whether or not it ’s wise to deliver two alike yield on The Girl of Steel on picture show and goggle box . But for those wanting to see Henry Cavill ’s Superman interact with television set ’s style of Supergirl , that ’s a job that Rothe could excel at , while making it her own .

6. Naomi Scott

If her role on the short - lived Fox seriesTerra Novashowed she had lead electric potential , then thePower Rangersmovie confirmed that Naomi Scott had really arrive . Anyone who miss out on the reboot does n’t need to take our discussion for it . Before long , Scott was signed by Disney in the coveted use ofPrincess Jasmine in their bouncy - legal action Aladdin motion picture . So if her star mightiness seems like less than Supergirl demand , that ’s about to change .

It ’s well - deserve , too . If WB plans to give young women a heroine who embraces superpowers , instead of being terrified by them , then Scott ’s posture and self-assurance will be put to safe use . And before anyone arrogate that Kara Zor - El needs to be Caucasic to match Henry Cavill ’s skin tone … permit ’s just not lay waste to time on that doubtfulness . Plus , Scott ’s native English accent would equip right in with most of the Kryptonians glimpsed inMan of Steel .

Page 2 of 2:Our Top 5 Picks For DCEU’s Supergirl

5. Saoirse Ronan

The longer rumors of aSupergirlmovie swirl , the more moviegoers are going to hear Saoirse Ronan ’s name mentioned as a top - tier choice - assuming that WB wants to keep pull in well-thought-of , spectacular thespian . And coming off an Oscar nomination and a Golden Globe profits for the starring office inLady Bird , a dive into the world of superhero could make sense . But just like Qualley , the picture show being planned would involve to make sense .

After all , Ronan does n’t demand a blockbuster potential enfranchisement as much as WB take a hit . So for buff expecting fully grown thing fromCaptain Marveldue to Brie Larson ’s own dramatic chops and awards , casting Ronan as the other major member of the Superman folk could be a compelling return . Ronan does n’t have much experience in military action since her number in Hanna , but … CG and training can take upkeep of that . seize that ’s even the case of movieSupergirlwill turn out to be .

4. Jessica Stroup

We should cue fans that if WB want to ensure their movie Supergirl abide aside from the TV series , they can change more than the style or tone . They can alter her long time : a adolescent waking up on Earth … or a grown woman emerging as an equal and peer to Superman . And if it ’s a thirty - something Kara that WB wants to bring to lifespan , that ’s a role that Jessica Stroup could encounter perfectly ( and would offer something newfangled to comic fans , as well ) .

Stroup will be known to comic book fans for her most late role as Joy Meacham on Marvel’sIron Fist , which some might take in as a hurdle to her bring such a high - profile film part . ButIron Fistviewers will also know that Stroup ’s performance deserves more than just recognition as one of the best parts of Marvel ’s worst get Netflix series to date . Like many mold members , Joy is remembered for what Stroup brought to the character - a blend of smarting and heart that a full - grown Kara should embody to stand opposite another Kryptonian hero .

3. Adria Arjona

ASupergirlmovie is just as likely to be fire by legal action as introspective drama . And if the movie go the first itinerary , then an actress like Adria Arjona will be up to the task , novel offPacific Rim : Uprising , and even more of late flexing her straightforward - cleaning lady drollery muscularity opposite Melissa McCarthy inLife of The Party . But that all comes second to Arjona ’s effortless behaviour as a serene , intelligent , and solemn hustler - no matter how feverish the fit in question .

If Supergirl fans do n’t get laid her yet ( and missed her leave role in the otherworldlyEmerald City ) then they will soon enough . Arjona will be starring alongside Ryan Reynolds inMichael Bay’s6 Undergroundfilm for Netflix , before step alongside Ben Affleck , Oscar Isaac , and Pedro Pascal inTriple Frontier . If they take to long to settle , WB may have trouble finding elbow room in Arjona ’s schedule at all .

2. Logan Browning

There are mint of ways that WB , or the filmmaker they bind can re - imagine or re - translate the storey of Supergirl for a feature of speech film . And fans will probably be more candid to experimentation than they were withMan of Steel , since a nostalgic rendering is presently air on The CW . But if they are looking to adjust the spirit of Kara in the most direct way potential , you ca n’t get much closer to it than Logan Browning .

TheDear White Peoplestar had a brief copse with comic Scripture superheroism in the short - livedPowers , but we think a less pert heroine function may actually be a better fit . Browning has read the cacoethes , sureness , and authority needed to make Supergirl a forcefulness to be reckoned with , which may be harder to pull off than most fans will believe . So it ’s a good matter Browning can also do justice to Kara ’s tenderness , confident position , and warmness ( while adding even more diverse cast to a motion picture universe already making it a precedency ) .

1. Natalie Dormer

We could n’t put together a list of actresses who could pull off Supergirl without acknowledging the heavier hitters and more ground actress fans will be clamoring for . And even before Marvel found its version of Carol Danvers , Natalie Dormer was a top selection among fans for both Marvel and DC . It ’s not gruelling to grasp why , since theGame of Thronesalum gave one of the across-the-board ranging , and fan - favorite performances of the show ’s run so far . sinewy , cunning , terrific , sweet , sexy , and slimy evil when fortune called for it , it ’s arduous to retrieve of a Supergirl story Dormer could n’t pull off on her sopor .

If the plan really is to put another Kryptonian standing opposite Henry Cavill ’s Superman , then Dormer makes plenty of dynamics potential . Few would ever doubt that she could allow Kal - El speechless or knocked back on his heels - and fall out it up with a smirk that give motion-picture fan exactly the sort of attitude they came to see . With a shot at Captain Marvel now off the table , will Dormer sign on for Supergirl to bring the same power to the fully grown screen ? We will just have to wait and see .

Chronicle Ending Explained - How Andrew Is Stopped In The Superhero Movie

MORE:WB Should Recruit James Gunn For DC Movie

In a dusty landscape Finn stares out into the distance in Star Wars: The Force Awakens

Supergirl Injustice Video Game

Imogen Poots Driving Need For Speed Movie Official

Margaret Qualley in The Leftovers

Tree (Jessica Rothe) screams at something offscreen in Happy Death Day.

Power Rangers - Naomi Scott as Kimberly (aka Pink Ranger)

Lady Bird sitting in a doorway

Jessica Stroup as Joy Meachum

Adria Arjona joins Good Omens cast

Dear White People Trailer

Margaery Tyrell in Game of Thrones reclines on a chair

Movies

Supergirl