Avengers: Infinity War
When Thanos snap his fingers at the cliffhanger ending ofAvengers : Infinity War , did he actually consign half the life in the universe of discourse to oblivion ? Or , instead , will next year’sAvengers 4reveal that the victim of the " snap " - including heroes like Spider - Man , Star - Lord , and Black Panther - were transport into the Soul World , a realm exist inside the Soul Stone , as many have speculate .
The location of the Soul Stone , last of the six Infinity Stones , was one of the abiding mysteries of the MCU . It was eventually revealed inAvengers : Infinity War , with Thanos memorise that it was hide on the distant humanity of Vormir . He sacrifice his daughter Gamora in lodge to get the Soul Stone , but barely used its power . Although necktie - in comics had describedthe Soul Stone as " the magnanimous terror " of all the Infinity Stones , the film itself did n’t even hint at what the Soul Stone could do . Thanos acquired it tardily in his quest , and the only clear affair he used it for was to lick out which Doctor Strange was real , and which were illusions .
Related : Every Time Thanos Used The Infinity Stones In Avengers : Infinity War
Given the Soul Stone ’s actual part inAvengers : eternity Warwas relatively underwhelming , it ’s hardly surprising that many TV audience are speculating it will be particularly important inAvengers 4 . A astonishingly common hypothesis suggests that it could well be central to undoing the " snap " itself .
The Soul Stone Theory Explained
The primal trouble ofAvengers : Infinity Waris thatthe cinema vote out characters we do it are due to return . Spider - Man : Far From Homeis currently in production , a movie set " instant after " the events ofAvengers 4 . Kevin Feige himself recently confirm thatDoctor foreign 2is certain to happen , while directorScott Derickson dropped a curious hintthat suggests pre - production could begin next month . There ’s also been square word aboutBlack Panther 2 , scarce a surprise given the film gross over $ 1.3 billion worldwide and essentially forced the Oscars to determine up a whole newfangled award , " Best Popular Film . " If three of the most important " snap " dupe are countersink to return , it ’s sane to assume that all of them will do so . Although some Marvel digit are still endeavor to persuade viewers these destruction will last ( most notably the Russo Brother ) , their attempts are in swollen-headed ; Thanos ’s dread act is distinctly destined to be undone , just as it was in the comics . The only question is , how ?
This is where the Soul Stone Theory follow in . agree to this possibility , Thanos did n’t in reality kill half the life history in the universe at all ; or else , they were consumed by the Soul Stone . In the funnies , the Soul Stone is a sentient being in its own right , and has a ravening desire to consume the souls of go existence . Anyone unfortunate enough to be consumed by the Soul Stone winds up pin down within a kingdom inside the Soul , known as the Soul World . significantly , it ’s quite potential to both escape the Soul World , and to be freed from it . The Soul Stone Theory suggest that the surviving Avengers will liberate their " asleep " colleagues from Soul World , take the battle to Thanos in one last conflict , and then free the sleep of the Soul Stone ’s victims too . Some even suggest that the original six Avengers will be the final sacrifices that pass the Soul Stone to release these victim ; " A psyche for a soul , " as the Red Skull hinted .
It ’s a compelling theory , and at first coup d’oeil it ’s strongly urge by the comics themselves . What ’s more , the Soul World did indeed come out inAvengers : Infinity War . When Thanos snap his digit , his consciousness was briefly transported into the Soul World , where he spoke to the spirit of Gamora , the charwoman he had sacrificed to the Soul Stone . give this is the case , the Soul Stone Theory has test compelling enough to persuade many viewers
But is the Soul Stone Theory true - or is it instead something of a red herring ?
Next Page:The Problems With The Soul Stone Theory
Avengers 4’s Time-Travel Arc Makes The Soul Stone Theory Worthless
The key problem with the Soul Stone Theory , though , is a simple one ; it ’s unneeded . The hypothesis supply an answer to the question of just how these missing and deceased Avengers will return , but all the grounds powerfully suggests Marvel is taking a dissimilar approach . Rather than explore the Soul World , they aim to use time - traveling .
refer : Ant - Man & The Wasp Director Wo n’t Rule Out Avengers 4 Time Travel hypothesis
Why would the Avengers be traveling through time ? The legitimate reasonableness is that they ’re attempting to rewrite history - specifically , to avert the result of the " snap . “Avengers 4isn’t aboutundoingthe " shot , " it ’s about ensuring it never happened in the first place . yield that ’s the pillow slip , the Soul Stone Theory is pretty much irrelevant . What does it count if Thanos ’s victims have been send into the Soul World ? prison term will be rewrite , so they were never sent there anyway . There is no penury for the Soul Stone Theory .
The Soul Stone Theory Doesn’t Explain the Vision
The shooting agenda ofAvengers 4came to an end in December 2017 , with scenes that seem to have call for both " snap " victims and survivors . Going by Instagram and societal media posts , there ’s evidence that Anthony Mackie , Dave Bautista , Elizabeth Olsen , Evangeline Lilly , Pom Klementieff , Tom Holland and Samuel L. Jackson - all killed by Thanos - were in Atlanta around the same time . It looks as though this was for a major " takings " scene , a aggregate resurrection of the dead heroes . But , crucially , there ’s one other actor substantiate to be on solidification at the time : Paul Bettany .
This is one resurrection that could n’t possibly be explain away by the Soul Stone Theory . Vision did n’t die as a result of the " snap . " Rather , he died when Thanos dip his helping hand into the humanoid ’s os frontale and seclude the Mind Stone . The " snap " could only happen because Vision was already dead . There ’s utterly no way Vision ’s individual - if he even has one - is trapped inside the Soul Stone . So any resurrection prospect logically has to imply something altogether different , say , the Avengers traveling back in time and foreclose Thanos killing him in the first lieu . Vision ’s return fits absolutely with the melodic theme thatAvengers 4is about time - travel , but it ca n’t maybe fit with the Soul Stone Theory .
The “Snap” Showed No Evidence of the Soul Stone’s Influence
The Soul Stone Theory is both unnecessary to the patch ofAvengers 4 , and insufficient when it come to explaining the Resurrection . Crucially , though , it also does n’t match with the item of the " snap " scene . VFX executive program Dan Deleeuw recently toldScreen Rantthat his squad originally considereda annihilation effect that ask all the different colors of the Infinity Stones , so as to show that the force of the six Stones was being united in this one horrendous act .
" [ It ] made sense that all six endocarp are compound now , [ so ] what stone would … how would combining the I. F. Stone make that happen ? So does the Soul Stone go in and decay their soul ? And does the Power Stone decompose the body ? And the Space Stone what actually moves the ash tree ? And so early tests were combine all those different pieces and although it was kind of beautiful in a fashion , it just became too much , correct ? It became … if there was too much of a Soul Stone effect it looked like they were on fire when they were disintegrate , and the estimation was like just back off and keep it simple . "
relate : Avengers 3 & Ragnarok Made A New Infinity Gauntlet Plot Hole
What ’s more , the very fact Thanos entered the Soul World straight off after the " snap " process against the possibility . He catches a brief coup d’oeil of a land that is barren and , aside from Gamora , wholly devoid of life . There ’s no lead that other souls are transition into the Soul World . As far asAvengers : Infinity Waris concerned , Gamora seems to be the only one trapped within .
Page 3 of 3:The Soul Stone’s REAL Role In Avengers 4
There is One Person Inside the Soul Stone
After year of build - up , it would be dissatisfactory if the Soul Stone were to testify largely irrelevant to the plot ofAvengers 4 . That ’s not the case , however , because the Soul Stone does carry one being trapped inside it - Gamora . Zoe Saldanahas already confirm that her character will return inAvengers 4 , and James Gunn planned for her to playa major role inGuardians of the Galaxy Vol . 3 . She may not have been one of the " snap " victims , but Gamora ’s story is far from over .
What ’s more , Avengers : eternity Wardropped an important hint as to how she could return . The Red Skull claim that one soul could be swap for another ; a being who loves Gamora could potentially give themselves so as to fetch her back . fortuitously for Gamora , there are three beings who would credibly be unforced to do so :
Related : Why Disney Is n’t Rehiring James Gunn For Guardians of the Galaxy 3
The most potential of these scenario is that , towards the end of the flick , Nebula will come to understand that she can offer herself in Gamora ’s stead . She will thus do so , sacrifice herself so that her sister can live . Regardless of who makes the ritual killing , though , it looks fairly sure that one will be made - and that the Soul Stone will be the basis of another emotional scene inAvengers 4 .
More:Avengers 4: What Role Do Thanos' Snap Victims Play?
