Avengers: Endgame
Joe and Anthony Russo ’s account for Captain America ’s terminate inAvengers : Endgameunfortunately make things big . After returning the Infinity Stones to their rightful place ( furbish up normality to the timeline ) , Steve Rogers choose to remain in the yesteryear and survive the life he was soak of after going into the ice during World War II . He returned from his time locomote journeyas a peaceable honest-to-goodness man , passing the Captain America blanket to Sam Wilson . Endgame’sfinal scene , one of the most cathartic moment in all of the MCU , shows Steve and Peggy Carter finally having their terpsichore - the complete bookend toThe First Avenger’stragic"I had a date"ending .
Once the naked as a jaybird emotion of seeing Steve and Peggy sway to " It ’s Been a farseeing , Long Time " wear off , fans debated about the logistics of the scene . Time travel can muck up thing up , and numerous theory were generate . The Russo brother attempted to reset the air by sayingSteve went to an alternating dimension to be with Peggy , and then arrive back to the meridian reality to say goodbye to Sam . But on a close examination , this explanation arguably makes the Steve / Peggy dance scene worse . The import of it are equal parts torturous and horrifying .
Related : Captain America ’s Sharon Carter Kiss ISN’T tough
For starters , it ’s a sad intellection to see Prime Peggy ( who audiences succeed through multiple MCU projects ) not convey the reunion people always desire to see . Yes , she eventually married and had a mob , but still spent year under the imprint Steve was dead ( while an alternate Peggy catch the terpsichore ) . In a direction , theEndgamescene is more meaningful to longtime viewers if it ’s the Prime Peggy . Additionally , the Russos ' logical thinking makesMarvel ’s decision to hide the identity of Prime Peggy ’s husbandsilly in retrospect , since it get the secrecy arbitrary or else of preservation of a massive revelation . Plus , there ’s also the idea that an alternate Steve will awake up and discover Peggy live with … a dissimilar him , somehow - which is pretty chilling ( Prime Steve took another Steve ’s Peggy ) . Another key interrogation raised by this explanation is how exactly our Steve jumpstart timeline , which is its own can of louse the Russos did not get into .
It seemed as if this was pass to be right canyon , butEndgamewriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely ( who infamouslydisagree with the Russos on the film ’s meter travel rules ) , suggested something else entirely . In their mind , Steve Rogers was always mean to be the forefather of Peggy ’s children , essentially makingEndgame’slast scene part of a shut time loop where Steve was Peggy ’s hubby all along . It ’s worth noting Markus and McFeely co - wrote theCaptain Americasolo trilogy and were probably pose the foundation for this for a farseeing time . Their account make more sense ( well , about as much mother wit as time travel high jinx can make ) because it reaffirm Prime Peggy and Prime Steve ended up together - no alternate Steve lives were ruined in this tearjerker - and simplifies things . It ’s easier to accept Steve traveled back to the past and last out in the setting while his younger self went through the events ofThe AvengersthroughEndgame . The Markus and McFeely explanation also makes Marvel ’s indisposition to portion out anything about Peggy ’s personal life understandable . If lover knew about the twist beforeEndgame , the view would n’t play with the same amount of vibrancy .
Unless someone at Marvel come in out and officially stamps one as true canon , Endgame’sfinal aspect will be open to interpretation . Some may even optto compare this to theInceptionendingand say it does n’t matter if Steve is in the prime timeline or an alternate timeline ; he get his terpsichore with his little girl . But that ’s an orchard apple tree - to - orange comparability . The Markus and McFeely job of logical thinking hold up more under closer review , keeping the lay down MCU intact without accrue apart at the seam . It ’s admittedly baffle the movie ’s directors and writers could n’t correspond on how this all worked and that only adds to the confusion . But with two explanations to select from , one might be the more preferable choice .
More : Why Captain America ’s Endgame Ending Is n’t a Plot Hole
