Related
At the beginning of theHarry Potterseries , Albus Dumbledorewas one of the most dear role . He came off as a benevolent kindly grandfather figure of speech , who only wanted the good for Hogwarts and all of its students ; as if the man could do no wrong .
As the series progressed , however , some gloomy secrets were unleashed about Dumbledore and he made some seriously confutable decisions . As the revelations and questions piled up , some fans actually stop up hating him by the prison term the book were over . Dumbledore was maybe always taste to do the good by those he cared about , but he messed up quite a few times in his decisions .
Awarding The House Cup To Gryffindor At The Last Second
It might have seemed like a small-scale misdemeanor at the prison term — if it seemed like one at all — but this was fairly messed up . At the conclusion ofHarry Potter And The Sorcerer ’s Stone , Slytherinhad enough point to gain the House Cup until Dumbledore awarded a bunch of random , last - second gunpoint to Harry and his supporter .
Sure , that was enceinte for them , but it was in reality passably disappointing to the young Slytherin child who lose out on their celebration . Slytherin is often treated as the evil house , but this merely is n’t true and was n’t bonnie to them at all . As a teacher , and just loosely as a homo , Dumbledore should have recognize this .
style to nurture theGryffindor and Slytherin rivalry .
Leaving Harry With The Dursleys
When Lily and James died , Dumbledore deemed family protection the most important thing for Harry . He strike the baby tothe Dursleysand left him on the doorstep with nothing but a letter explaining that his aunty and uncle would have to raise him now .
We can all see the system of logic there , as Harry needed the blood protection fromVoldemort , but it was a duple - edged sword . Dumbledore condemn him to a life of neglect and abuse and did n’t really hoist a finger’s breadth to try and avail him — even when he was really struggling . Surely a wizard as powerful as Dumbledore could have protected Harry in some other manner — or at the very least , countenance him stay atHogwartsover the summertime vacation .
Hiding The Truth From Harry
In universal , Dumbledore was n’t really fairish to Harry . He was perpetually hide the accuracy from him . He knew of the vaticination from pretty much the Nox it was spoken , and never annoy to tell Harry about it until he found out himself . Even then , he lie , never tell Harry he was going to have to die to save the world . He was grooming him for a really tragic ending .
Dumbledore ’s reasoning for this was that he did n’t want Harry to be wretched , but he forget Harry with the Dursleys until he was 11 , so he clearly did n’t require him to be glad above all else .
Avoiding Harry When He Was Nearly Possessed By Voldemort
InHarry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix , Harry ended up semi - possessed by Voldemort for most of the twelvemonth . Voldemort would randomly enter his head and they would share moods and emotions though neither of them were quite cognisant of what was happening for most of it .
Dumbledore was , though .
And rather than just explicate to Harry and teach him Occlumency himself , he brush off Harry . He left him desperate , upset , and wild because he did n’t want Voldemort to be able to sight on him . And what about Harry , who was force to let Voldemort recruit his brain ? Comeon , Dumbledore .
Ignoring Snape’s Abuse Towards The Students
Did he ever pick up disciplinary action ? Not that we know of .
Seriously , did him spying on Voldemort somehow give him the right to be absolutely horrible to children ?
Continuing The Defense Against The Dark Arts Post
When Dumbledore turned downTom Riddlefor the Defense Against The Dark Arts Wiley Post , he put a swearword on it . This had to think that fordecades , they were running through one teacher a yr who was drive out at the end in some unpleasant circumstance because the post was cursed .
It ’s important to defend yourself , but keeping this subject just did n’t seem worth it . Could n’t they have scrapped it and put defense in with something else , or changed the case enough to lift the curse ? Or could n’t Dumbledore have tried harder to break it , since he was more knock-down than Voldemort ? Seems like a wretched use of resource not to .
Keeping Sirius In Grimmauld Place
When Sirius got out ofAzkabanand became part of the Order , Dumbledore was compulsive to keep him interlace up in Grimmauld Place . Yes , he wanted Sirius to avoid capture , which is fair enough , but that was a home that carry lots of terrible memories for him . It was a home he was presumptively maltreat in , judging by the portrait of his female parent and reputation of his family .
Even Dumbledore acknowledged that when Sirius became reckless and got himself killed , operate him that house was to find fault . And then miserable Harry cease up blaming himself . Dumbledore was definitely kind of at mistake here .
Allowing Harry To Participate In The Triwizard Tournament
We have intercourse Voldemort is hear to occur back by the timeHarry Potter And The Goblet Of Firerolls around . Dumbledore is well aware of the fact . So when Harry ’s name pops out of the goblet and he ’s tell apart he has to participate indangerous project , would n’t the best thing to do be to ban him ?
NEXT:10 Canonical Facts That Make Dumbledore A Not-So-Nice Person
Nope . Dumbledore decides it ’s best to countenance him participate . And even McGonagall has questions .
Movie Dumbledore is so much bad about it , but book Dumbledore should also have withdrawn Harry immediately . What did he gestate to happen here ? It was always going to have a bad end .
