Related
Come the death of 2019 , fans ofStar Warswill be able to have the concluding chapter of the sequel trilogy . Love it or detest it , it will undeniably be an unbelievable moment for scientific discipline fiction fans , bringing a closing curtain to the Skywalker Saga .
But scientific discipline fiction fans should n’t cry too intemperately . After all , Denis Villeneuve will be bringing another sci - fi larger-than-life to the big cover : Dune . Frank Herbert’sDuneremains the pillar of skill fable storytelling ; it’sThe Lord of the Ringsof the genre . No other taradiddle has ever impacted the scientific discipline fiction musical genre likeDune . In fact , Dunein many way inspired George Lucas .
So doesDunehave a chance at being a sound film thanStar Wars Episode IX ? It certainly has a chance at being better … but it is n’t a warranty .
(Dune) A Focused Narrative
The problem with several science fiction space stories is that the story becomes diffuse out . There is a desire to show the whole universe , and , thus , things straggle out of control . The Last Jedi , for example , feature no less than four separate planets — to say nothing of the scenes in infinite .
WhileDunedoes feature multiple planets as well — most notably Caladan and Giedi Prime — the bulk of the story read position on Arrakis . While many science fiction fans might be disappointed by the lack of variety , the focus on one planet really ground the story . It saves the storytellers clip on explore the whole universe . It keep the conflict focused and squiffy . What happens on Arrakis , after all , affects billions of star systems .
(Star Wars) Carrie Fisher’s Legacy
Carrie Fisher pass beforeThe Last Jediwas release , but her legacy carry on intoStar Wars Episode IX , which will be her final film visual aspect . While this may not affect the plot of land too drastically ( the movie was written with Carrie Fisher ’s pass in mind ) , every scene feature the late actress will carry such incredible weighting knowing the in - universe and real - life context of her presence .
Even fans who detest the Disney era ofStar Warscan admit this will add an worked up level to the film .
(Dune) An Incredible Cast
There is no doubt thatStar Warshas a with child cast of actors . It would be foolish to pick apart the acting talent of Daisy Ridley , John Boyega , Oscar Isaac , orAcademy Award Nominee Adam Driver . However , if one compare the sheer clout ofDune’scast to the form ofStar Wars Episode IX … one ca n’t help but get a small airheaded just look at it .
ignore the fact that Oscar Isaac is also inDune , Dunehas Dave Bautista , Stellan Skarsgard , Zendaya , Javier Bardem , Jason Momoa , Josh Brolin — these are all well - fuck stars , playing characters that seem dead suitable to their talents . To say nothing of the thespian playing protagonist Paul Atreides : Academy Award Nominee Timothée Chalamet .
possibly all the actors will do a terrible caper . Maybe the flick will not be a union of its parts . But this cast should make you excite .
(Dune) We Already Know the Story
Star Wars Episode IX’splot is a mystery . No one knows what will come about in that moving picture . As indicated with the fan theory debacle that circulatedThe Last Jedi , literally no one has any idea what to gestate with that film . This could be unbelievable or atrocious — again , reckon on your viewpoint of the picture show .
However , we already know the fib ofDune . The Quran came out in the 1960s . While Denis Villeneuve will inevitably take liberties with the source textile ( and only conform the first half of the story ) , there is no mystery about the general plot of land of the film . This entail the precariousness and expectancy about the plot workings probably wo n’t be a agent . The only question is will the book be well - adapted .
(Star Wars) No Restrictions On Creativity
The toss - side of the coin is that , since we already cognise the game ofDune , any liberties take will be treated with literary criticism by buff . While Denis Villeneuve will be able-bodied to tell a great story on the grown screen , he will be simultaneously shackle to the source textile .
J. J. Abrams has no such restrictions . He can do whatever he wants . He can make any creative choice , and fans will just have to accept it . Because it could very well work . And , afterThe Last Jedi , fan in all likelihood wo n’t be surprise by an insane numeral of spin Abrams wants to pull .
(Dune) Denis Villeneuve
J. J. Abrams is an unbelievable director . We know he can fetch his natural endowment to theStar Warsfranchise quite successfully , as shew withThe Force Awakens . However , it can not be understated that fans of Frank Herbert ’s playscript should be overjoy that Denis Villeneuve is work out onDune .
Denis Villeneuve is one of the best last directors working flop now . Blade Runner 2049was an incredible sci - fi epic , but , beyond that , he brought the worldSicarioandPrisoners , two fabulously tense films that offered audiences an unforgettable experience . Any Villeneuve movie is desirable of the hype . But him tackling one of the most influential piece of work of sci - fi ever ? Even better .
(Star Wars) Pure Spectacle
modernistic sci - fi fans , however , may be surprised to learn that most ofDunetakes place in a desert . It is more aGame of Thrones - esque story of equal royal houses contend . feint - within - feints - within - feint rather than starship battles or shootout . Sure , there are fights , but they ’re more means to an end .
Dunewill not show hearing the sheer spectacle of quad adventure and fantasy that everyStar Warsfilm — even the worst among them — offers . Regardless of the quality of the game , Star Warsmovies propose a spectacle that blows audience away . And , regardless of what people think of the sequel trilogy , the films in it pack a lot of bosom , so the chronological sequence wo n’t just be explosions , but emotionally vivid moments to boot .
The want of star fights inDunemight genuinely disappoint modern musical genre fan .
(Dune) Shakespearean Tragedy
Duneisn’t a spectacle story . It is , however , a dramatic play of Shakespearean legacy .
WhileDunecertainly influencedStar Wars(especially in Lucas ’s earlier order of payment ) , a well mod equivalence to Dune is George R. R. Martin’sGame of Thrones . Both feature tons of characters with complex , virtuously equivocal natures competing on a political and physical field of battle . Children neglected by the secret plan of their family ’s opposer are will to fester and ordain revenge .
It is unfeignedly Shakespearian in nature .
(Star Wars) The Weight Of A Legacy
Star Wars Episode IXis the 11th theatricalStar Warsfilm . It stands as the culmination of everything that came before it . Because of that , by the time the quotation roll , the film will leave a resonating weight on the shoulder joint of its audience , for undecomposed or bad .
Because of that , Star Wars Episode IXis less a film and more of a ethnic landmark in the fashioning . Everyone is going to see it , disregardless of what you thought of any of the prior moving picture . The exercising weight of the saga make this moving picture find more vivid than an ordinary photographic film . For that understanding alone , Episode IXis an outcome .
(Dune) No Legacy
Ironically , despite creating many of the tropes and concepts sci - fi films likeStar Warsripped off — and despite having over 20 novels in its series — Duneitself has little cinematic legacy . The David Lynch adaptation from the ' 80s is a cult classic with its fans ( including the writer of this article ) , as well as two miniseries created forSyFy(back when it was still calledThe Sci - Fi Channel ) . However , not a single one of these equivalence to the bequest of George Lucas’sStar Wars .
NEXT:How George Lucas' Star Wars 9 Ended The Saga Completely Differently
Star Wars Episode IX , before it even get out , will be compare to every film that came before it . Dunewill be compared to its original novel . Its fans have been so starved of quality contentedness that they will see this film as their own haven in the desert . It does n’t have to come after the rule of 10 prior films in a enfranchisement or deport over topic started by a unlike theatre director back in the ' LXX . It just has to be good .
And in the coming decade , is n’t it refreshing to determine a sci - fi film without ranking it on a list of 11 film , and being force to have an opinion in an more and more divisive debate?Dunemight be more exciting to watch thanStar Wars Episode IXbecause , after learn it , you wo n’t be drafted into a war establish on your opinion .
