Related
No tyrant is unadulterated without an United States Army . For Lord Voldemort inHarry Potter , the Death Eaters were his chief soldiers .
The rubric of Death Eater was given to Voldemort ’s following , witches and wizards who followed his ordering and enforced his will during the First and Second Wizarding Wars . They had to followstrict rulesin order to link up these ranks and serve Voldemort .
Bellatrix Lestrange , Severus Snape , and Lucius Malfoy are among the most memorable characters who act in the role of Death Eater .
Not everything about the Death Eaters makes complete sense , though . The Death Eaters made confutable decisions , as did Voldemort when it fall to managing his followers .
The Ministry of Magic also made a number of head - scratching calls when it came to the Death Eaters , both in the consequence of the First Wizarding War and during the Second Wizarding War .
When baby Harry Potter seemed to defeat Voldemort once and for all and the Dark Lord disappeared , each Death Eater reacted other than .
These reaction and the outcome that they buckle under are decidedly worth looking at , as they offer a great deal of insight into what does and does not make sensory faculty about the Death Eaters .
The Second Wizarding War is just as authoritative to examine as the aftermath of the First Wizarding War , though , when it occur to the Death Eaters .
With that say , here are the20 thing That Make No Sense About The Death Eaters InHarry Potter .
Rodolphus And Rabastan Lestrange Were Ignored By Voldemort
When Voldemort disappeared , only his most loyal Death Eaters– Bellatrix Lestrange , Barty Crouch Jr. , Rodolphus Lestrange , and Rabastan Lestrange– hear to find the Dark Lord .
They rack Aurors Frank and Alice Longbottom to the point of insanity in an attempt to extract information . For this crime and others , all four Death Eaters received lifespan imprisonment in Azkaban .
Years later , Bellatrix and Crouch Jr. would be give crucial roles in Voldemort ’s return to power .
Despite face the same fate as Bellatrix and Crouch Jr. and indicate the same loyalty , Rodolphus and Rabastan were deal like any other Death Eaters .
Given their action at law , they should ’ve been given important stead like Bellatrix and Crouch Jr.
A Lot Of Them Went Back To Normal Life After The First Wizarding War
Some Death Eaters tried to forfend a life conviction in Azkaban by ratting out others ' identity or claim that they ’d been under the Imperius Curse the entire time .
It ’s one affair to accept that these actions give up them to evade Azkaban , but it ’s another thing entirely to accept that these Death Eaters were allow to reenter society without consequence .
They were set aside to retain their wealthiness and hold up many important positioning , even in the world of education among impressionable children .
Just because the creation consider that Voldemort was truly move and these somebody did n’t merit prison , it did n’t mean that they were no longer threat to high society .
Igor Karkaroff Was Able To Become A Headmaster
Many Death Eaters ' identities were a secret , even among fellow Death Eaters . This made round off them up them up difficult for the Ministry of Magic in the aftermath of the First Wizarding War .
Igor Karkaroff used this to his vantage , revealing the name of Death Eaters who the Ministry still call for to catch . In exchange , Karkaroff was n’t sentenced to immurement in Azkaban .
This makes sense , but Karkaroff becoming the Headmaster at Durmstrang after these events is a different taradiddle .
Even for a school day like Durmstrang and their penchant for the Dark Arts , charter Karkaroff seems like a wicked idea . He was a known Death Eater and proved by tell on that he had no trouble backing out on former promise to save his own skin .
These are not quality a school wants in a Headmaster responsible for for the education and well - being of children .
Sirius Black Never Had The Dark Mark
When Voldemort line up Lily and James Potter and took their life despite the Fidelius Charm protecting them , everyone knew their Secret - Keeper must ’ve deceive them .
As the longtime best ally of James and fellow Order of the Phoenix member , it seemed that Sirius Black must ’ve been the Potters ' Secret - Keeper . Peter Pettigrew ’s fake death and his " concluding words " seemed to support that Sirius was not only the treasonist , but also Voldemort ’s right - hand .
Even without knowing the real story of Peter ’s treachery , the narrative of Sirius being a Death Eater and Voldemort ’s correct - hand should ’ve been undone by the fact that he was n’t branded with a Dark Mark .
Only Voldemort ’s inner circle were branded with the Dark Mark .
The fact that Sirius did n’t have one should ’ve been damning evidence that he was free .
Lucius Malfoy’s Educational Position
Lucius Malfoy avoided Azkaban by claim that everything he ’d done as a Death Eater had been under the Imperius Curse .
This should ’ve been dubious give the Malfoy family history . Even in a scenario where this was true , though , Lucius subsequently becoming a School Governor of Hogwarts seems like a poor determination .
Anyone who wait on Voldemort– even if they were under the Imperius Curse– should n’t be allowed to make decisions regarding a school , its teachers , or scholar .
Lucius got off too slowly and should n’t have been able to take a position of influence .
Why Did Voldemort Believe Snape’s Story?
When Voldemort returned to power with a strong-arm word form inHarry Potter and the Goblet of Fire , he summoned all of the Death Eaters to him through the Dark Mark .
Death Eaters who did n’t answer the bidding and were n’t in Azkaban would later pay the cost , such as Igor Karkaroff , who was run down and terminated for his defiance .
Severus Snape , on the other hand , arrived two hour after the bidding , claiming that he ’d waited to insure Albus Dumbledore that he was loyal to him even though his lawful loyalty were to Voldemort .
Even with Snape ’s domination at Legilimency , which prevented Voldemort from extract the the true from his mind , Voldemort should ’ve control through Snape ’s fib .
Ever since Voldemort ’s fade , Snape would ’ve been influenced by Dumbledore and him alone . This and the two hour postponement should ’ve been ruby-red flags for Voldemort , but he trusted Snape profoundly , a trust that would lead to the Dark Lord ’s eventual downfall .
Not Every Death Eater Was A Pure-blood
Voldemort ’s regime mostly revolved around the estimate of pure pedigree . The family tree of each Death Eater needed to solely comprise of pure - blooded wizards and witch .
Any ravishment of this required " pruning , " which was seen when Bellatrix needed to take the lives of Remus Lupin and Nymphadora Tonks , as a loup-garou and his bride could not be part of her house tree .
The problem is that few of the Death Eaters ' bloodlines could really be saturated .
Severus Snape ’s Father of the Church was a Muggle , create him a half - blood .
Even before Lupin entered the Lestrange - Black family tree diagram , Bellatrix ’s baby Andromeda conjoin the Muggle Ted Tonks , whose daughter would later wed Lupin .
The Death Eaters hat and look for to destroy those whose family tree were n’t pure , yet their own kin could n’t match these standards .
Why Didn’t Voldemort Use The Imperius Curse On More People?
When Harry departed Privet Drive with the Order of the Phoenix at the head start ofHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , they were pursued across the sky by Voldemort and the Death Eaters .
Harry encountered an Imperiused Stan Shunpike fight alongside Death Eaters during this pastime . The Knight Bus conductor was no Voldemort comforter , yet he had no choice but to to dish the Dark Lord under the Imperius Curse .
Stan was n’t the only one like this , but it seems like there should ’ve been far more .
Voldemort ’s rank could ’ve become far greater with more Imperiused individuals like Stan fighting alongside this Death Eaters .
Why Did Voldemort Want To Recruit Horace Slughorn?
Horace Slughorn was a Slytherin and the favorite teacher of Tom Riddle . Still , Slughorn was no rooter of dark magic and would never volitionally enter in supporting Voldemort ’s regime .
This throws into interrogative why the Death Eaters would examine to inscribe Slughorn . After all , he was trying to hold in specific computer memory from Harry and Dumbledore after they find him at the start ofHarry Potter and the Half - Blood Prince .
It ’s much more potential that Voldemort wanted the Death Eaters to eliminate Slughorn as his memories revealed the truth about Voldemort ’s Horcruxes .
The recruitment idea was all incorrect and might have been an lesson of how Slughorn flatter himself even with his living on the line .
Lucius Malfoy Shouldn’t Have Been Voldemort’s Right-Hand Man
Lucius Malfoy was put into a leadership position with the Death Eaters at the Department of Mysteries inHarry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix . Voldemort ’s trust in Lucius does n’t make much sentiency , though .
Unlike the Lestranges– who at this time had get away from Azkaban and were present at the Department of Mysteries– Lucius did n’t search for Voldemort after his disappearing .
Lucius even denied loyalty to Voldemort by claiming that everything he ’d done as a Death Eater occurred while he was under command of the Imperius Curse .
In the twelvemonth since , Lucius also gave away the diary that Voldemort entrust to him , a journal that was a Horcrux hold a piece of Voldemort ’s soul .
The action of Lucius led to its destruction .
His want of loyalty and failure to safeguard the Horcrux should ’ve prevented him from lead the Death Eaters at the Department of Mysteries , where he failed again .
