Related
There are few franchises as generation - limit and globally appealing as ‘ Harry Potter . ’ From the well - sell books to the critically acclaimed films , it was once consider the pinnacle of franchise direction . But then writer and creator J.K. Rowling found chirrup and used the online social media platform as a medium to expose more and more of her cosmos ’s traditional knowledge . That evolve into her signing off on ‘ The Cursed Child , ’ a two - part microscope stage play that bring out the kind of ludicrously convolute plots that time travel story have been realize fun of since meter travel was first introduced as a narrative convention .
As if that was n’t enough , Warner Bros. became desperate enough to produce a spin - off series base on the backstory of the author of one of Harry ’s least - cite text edition . This three - pronged attack has more or less laid waste to the ‘ Harry Potter ’ persistence as Rowling gleefully retcons and overexplains her own existence . Sometimes this is simply to include new representation , sometimes it ’s actually to intensify characters or plot points . As with any illumination of auctorial purport , this can be a adept thing or a bad affair . In Rowling ’s case , it ’s more often a mistake than an addition , but she ’s said more than a few thing that have made improvements on her original workplace . Here ’s a list of the 15 worst and 8 best retroactive changes she ’s made to ‘ Harry Potter . ’
Worst: Fred Was Born First
For whatever intellect , Rowling felt it was absolutely necessary to establish that , between the infamously mischievous Weasley twins , Fred was tolerate a few proceedings before George . aside from the obvious question of why she call up her fans were despairing for this information , there ’s also the subject of Fred never land this up in the books . Knowing their personality , Fred dead would have lorded this over George ’s oral sex as often as he could . If Rowling had thought of this little fun fact when she was actually writing the fabric , she would have include this as a running joke .
Worst: Divination Isn’t Real
Readers remember the ditzy Professor Trelawney as Harry ’s scatter brained instructor of divination , the artwork of predicting the future tense through various bizarre methods . While she seemed somewhat ostentatious and full of it , her prophecy concerning who could end Voldemort ’s sovereignty of holy terror is the actuate incident of the entire enfranchisement ’s narrative . So needless to say , fans were more than a fiddling riled that Rowling later confirm that divination was just elementary poppycock . Why did the whole series even happen then ? !
Best: Why Harry Didn’t Name A Kid ‘Remus’
irrespective of what might have happened with ‘ Cursed tiddler , ’ the epilogue to ‘ Deathly Hallows ’ was a adorable picture of the peace that Harry and his friends finally found . As a bonus , Rowling later tweeted that Harry himself had hope for the repose to endure as prove by his kids names . Namely , he never named one after his late booster Remus Lupin so that Remus ’s son Teddy could one day use the name for one of his own kids . Now that ’s thinking in advance .
Worst: Dumbledore And Grindelwald Had An Intense Relationship
Rowling ’s verification that Dumbledore was merry was basically what set off her habit of retconning and rewriting her work after the fact . But she take it a tone too far when , years later , she went out of her elbow room to support that Dumbledore and his make bold lover Grindelwald did indeed have a physical family relationship . Even Stephen Colbert went out of his way to talk about how TMI this was . First off , nobody cares , most people assumed as much anyway . Second off , Rowling discussing this feels like a mom talking about her kids in this manner . It ’s just creepy-crawly .
Worst: Crookshanks Is A Half-Magic Cat
In the books , Crookshanks , Hermione ’s rowdy pet qat , was a fun lilliputian diversion . Hermione have a go at it him , Ron and Harry were a little more apprehensive of a gutter bozo being digressive to their immediate friend chemical group , and nobody else really cared . But Rowling decide that Crookshanks , who had a set frumpy personality anyway , involve to be explained in more detail . Turns out Crookshanks is half - Kneazle , a metal money of magical CT that have estimable judgement . Why , Rowling ? Why ca n’t you just let us have overnice matter ?
Best: Hagrid Can’t Produce A Patronus
Despite Hagrid ’s broadly speaking upbeat personality , he ’s the role that the serial publication most routinely messes with . He gets expelled for a offense he did n’t commit , is never allowed to dispatch his education , has been under arrest multiple times on false charges , and he lose his family at a untried years . Nevertheless , he always seems pollyannaish and fairly , like a hippy Santa . Rowling clarified that this was all an act as Hagrid is unequal to of summoning the happy memories needed to cast a Patronus charm .
Worst: Nagini Was A Cursed Asian Woman
This one was insulting on multiple level . When Rowling announced prior to the release of ‘ Fantastic creature and the Crimes of Grindelwald ’ that she ’d always intended Voldemort ’s loyal snake to be an Asiatic woman blaspheme to sour into an animal , it not only insulted the intelligence of her consultation who be intimate she was making it up on the fly , but also to her Asian reader who attend one of only two striking Asian role in the franchise being used as a real positron emission tomography . Just so Rowling could have her precious retro representation .
Worst: Legilimency Can Be A Natural Skill
In the book , Legilimency was Rowling ’s pedestal - in for ESP . It was a wizard ’s artwork of navigate through one ’s mind through a magic charm . But then the ‘ antic Beasts ’ movies hustle around and Rowling adjudicate it would be fun ( read : stupid ) if one of her raw character was so good at Legilimency that she was basically just a psychic . Enter Queenie Goldstein . How she ’s capable to do this naturally is never explained , but it ’s safe to assume that Rowling just decided that there are random Charles Xaviers popping up every now and again in the wizarding existence .
Best: Fluffy Was Sent Back To Greece
One of the first iconic range of a function to add up out of the series was that of the three supporter walk in on Fluffy , the giant hellhound that Hagrid fix up to guard the Sorcerer ’s Stone . As instantly awesome as Fluffy was , he never manage to erect his three heads in the series again . Rowling authorise this up in a tweet saying that Dumbledore had repatriate Fluffy back to Greece and that the headmaster was able-bodied to prevail in some of Hagrid ’s more … adventurous exploits with magical creatures .
Worst: Time-Turners Can Go Back Decades
Ah , time change of location , ye bane of narrative story - telling . No taradiddle can contend with thine ability to whole rewrite everything that happen with footling to no explanation . Which is why when Rowling first insert the charming time - Joseph Mallord William Turner gadget to her universe , she was quick to establish that it could only take a user five hours into the past , smartly restricting its impact on her story . But then she helped write ‘ Cursed Child ’ where lineament go decades into the past with the gimmick . And ye , a terrible stageplay was molded .
