Related
It ’s fair to say that whenLord of the band : society of the Ringdebuted back in 2001 , it blow more than a few people ’s brain .
For rooter ofThe Lord of the Rings , it was the great - budget spare - no - effort faithful adaptation that they were wait for . Though some particular were alter or lose in the transition to the movie , by in large it had the look and feel of the Middle - ground that many fans farm up loving .
For those who were brand new to the tarradiddle , or who never finish the ledger , the tale was an astounding introduction to a realm of phantasy that they had never seen before . The rich backstory made this world seemed lived in and real . It single - handedly redefine what a phantasy film could look like .
Not only did it make a trillion dollar , but it also complain off a fantasy enfranchisement that became an crying classic . These are live , breathe fairy narrative that fan stream over and watch again and again , likeStar WarsorHarry Potter .
However , perhaps it ’s because of these repeated wake that dedicated fans have unearthed an telling set of plot yap .
When world - building an entirely alternative history , it give out with the soil that you might accidentally create a few things that are n’t quite logical . Some of these discrepancies rest solely on the shoulder of the original writer , J.R.R. Tolkien , while others seem to fall more on Peter Jackson and his adaptation .
Regardless , like any classical work , it is n’t sodding .
Here are the20 Things About The Fellowship InLord Of The RingsThat Make No Sense .
If The Nazgul Hate Water So Much, Why Not Travel By Boat?
It ’s made clear in theFellowship of the Ringthat the Ringwraiths do n’t particularly like water . They ’ll ride through shallow piss but they would really prefer not to . They ’re also not exactly sailors , so you ’re not going to see them on ships .
So why did n’t the Fellowship take a boat for most the way ? You could get on the Brandywine River from Hobbiton head up Cicily Isabel Fairfield until you get to the sea , then sail south down the coast all the way to South Gondor .
From there , you could go about Mordor from the south , until you pass on the bag of the mountains .
There would be no round , no orcs , no giant spiders , and most importantly , no Ringwraiths– at least until you make landfall .
The elves know how to sweep . Why was n’t this an alternative ?
Why Is Gandalf So Stingy With His Magic?
Gandalf just uses any trick at all , but when he does , it ’s a showstopper . However , it always seems like the Fellowship has to be close to finished before he pulls something out of his bag of tricks .
When present by the mammoth Balrog in the Mines of Moria , Gandalf single - handedly hold him off with his wizard faculty , announcing , “ You shall not pass ! ” Though he seemingly pop off from the fall , we determine out later on that he survives .
subsequently , while Gandalf is on horseback , he fends off a wing Ringwraith simply by curl his staff around . He battle orcs like a one - man regular army inReturn of the King , using a combination of swordplay and thaumaturgy .
Why did n’t he use his magic when they were bushwhack by Orcs in the mine ?
Why Aren’t More Elves In The Fellowship?
Legolas is an amazing addition to any questing political party . The sheik is a genius with a bow , and he can also make fast body of work out of enemies with his two blade . sparkle on his foot , he is agile and accurate , with probably the easily sodding stamina on the team .
Better yet , he never complains and seems to be able to make friends with everyone , even Gimli .
So why are n’t there more extremely low frequency on the squad ? It seems like a no - brainer to trade the useless Merry and Pippen for a couplet of extremely low frequency like Legolas .
The elves are about to sweep for distant lands as the War of the Ring approaches . Still , if they can spare a few elves for the Battle of Minas Tirith , they ought to be able to give at least one more to the Fellowship .
Why Didn’t Gandalf Bring Fireworks For Defensive Purposes?
Gandalf ’s pyrotechnic display at Bag End designate that he has a advanced apprehension of explosives .
His finale was a firework that took the form of a dragon made of fire and swooped low over the crew before erupting into a huge multi - explosion video display .
If Gandalf can make pyrotechnic seem like dragons , why was n’t he be able-bodied to make something practical in warfare , like a bomb calorimeter or a grenade ?
live on further with this idea , should n’t Gandalf have mob some explosive with him for the purpose of demurrer ? They would have been handy in the Mines of Moria to light up up the night and confuse the Orcs .
Perhaps it just was n’t his panache . However , it seems like a lay waste to chance .
Why Are Four Hobbits A Part Of It?
So dissemble you ’re building a society to ensure that the One Ring gets destroyed . Frodo , the ring - bearer is the one Hobbit you have to have — his very nature is the least venal and thus he is the safest individual to actually hold the Ring .
An tilt can be made that Sam is important for Frodo ’s moral as well as for logistic backing .
However , why are there two other Hobbits , Merry and Pippin ? What do they bring to the table other than kick that they have n’t had second breakfast yet ?
Sure they helped to recruit the Ents to intercept Saruman , but they did n’t really do much of the heavy lifting .
You ’d think that they ’d stack the Fellowship deck with a few more warriors . Merry and Pippen are about as useful on the misstep as teenagers who complain they have no Badger State - fi .
Why Isn’t Radagast The Brown In The Fellowship?
Radagast the Brown urinate a bit of a splash in the books and also appears inThe Hobbitprequel movies . However , he is nowhere to be discover during the great War of the Ring . Nor is he mentioned . Why ?
As a powerful wizard with nature on his side , he would have been a gravid ally . He could have at least convince the Ents to bring together the fight earlier .
In the account book , an attack was made to enrol him into the fight , but they could not feel him at home . You ’d think that with all of the magic they ’d find a way to transmit with him somehow .
In J.R.R. Tolkien’sUnfinished Tales , he mentions that Radagast ’s genuine tariff was to defend fauna and plant life , something that would have taken all his tending regardless of the termination of the War of the Ring . However , sure enough the War of the Ring would have affect both plants and animals .
Why Not Use The Giant Eagles To Drop The Ring Into Mt. Doom?
We all thought it when we saw it . At the end ofReturn of the King , Frodo and Sam are saved from the volcanic thriftlessness of Mount Doom by gargantuan eagles that come to deliver them .
“ But wait , ” we ’re think , “ if the eagles can just vanish to Mount Doom , then why did the Hobbits hike for three movies to get there ? ”
They could have avoided the Mines of Moria , Golem , and Shelob , and the other great scurf conflict of Helm ’s Deep and Minas Tirith would never have had to happen .
M of aliveness would have been save .
The hardcore fans have hypothesis for this , drift from a complex codification of honor from the eagles to “ the fly Ringwraiths would have bar them . ”
However , should n’t they have try ? Or at the very least , given them a lift partway ?
Why Don’t Gandalf Or The Elves Realize That Boromir Might Be Problematic?
The human Boromir became corrupted by the Ring and tried to slip it . However , this was arguably out of despair to spare his people . He eventually made secure by realise his wrongs and sacrifice his living to save the Fellowship .
However , was there not anyone who could see Boromir ’s perfidy occur ?
Aragorn , as heir to the King , seemed like a must - have on the company . As a fellow human and comrade - in - arms , could n’t he pick up clues that peradventure Boromir was n’t on the up and up ?
Also , what about Gandalf and Elrond ? They are two of the wisest fiber in Middle - earth . Could n’t they see Boromir ’s designs and indebtedness from at least a stat mi away ?
It seems like even centuries - old being and magical wizards are just crappy at read multitude sometimes .
Why Did Bilbo never see Sauron when he used the ring?
Perhaps the easier answer here is that as an author , J.R .. R. Tolkien perhaps did not have the whole floor flesh out yet , so he even he did not reckon the full significance of the Ring as he was writingThe Hobbit .
Still , the inconsistency is jarring . Bilbo seems to apply the Ring freely with little hurt at all , until much later in aliveness when he becomes attached to it . This is a period of almost a generation .
Frodo , on the other hand , part to become corrupted by the Ring by the very end of the third movie , which arguably happens in less than a year . He also begin to have visions of Sauron almost forthwith upon using the Ring .
Did Bilbo have a solid spirit than Frodo ? Or was Frodo , for whatever reason , more susceptible to it ?
Why Did They Not Attempt To Recruit The Ents?
Though they make no contact in the pic , Gandalf and Elrond must have known about the Ents . It ’s possible that even Gimli had heard of them , so it ’s baffling that none of them were recruited .
In The Two Towers , the Hobbits have a hard time convincing the Ents to get call for until they see whole groves of trees being gain out for the Orcs ’ project .
If that is all it takes , would n’t a high - level “ show and tell ” mission be so as to get the giant and brawny Ents involved in the conflict ?
These beingness seem at least as strong , if not more so , than the enemy ’s goliath trolls . They also have the summate incentive of being easily disguised as a tree when they specify up camp .
However , they only get involved in part of the conflict because of happenstance .
