Related
TheMCU ’s Phase 1 post - credits scene are fun , but they do n’t in reality make sense at all . According to Kevin Feige , the MCU ’s post - credits scenes came into being because of his own beloved of movies back when he was a adolescent . " As a film dweeb , I never want it to finish , " he reflected . " I did n’t want the experience … no matter how good or bad the movie was , just the experience of being in the movie theater , I did n’t want to end . So I would always sit through the credits . "
Marvel did n’t make up the thought of the post - credits scene ; in fact , the first ever post - credits aspect was in 1903 , when the main fictional character seemed to return from the dead to point a gun at the audience inThe Great Train Robbery . But since 2008 they ’ve become strongly associated with the Marvel trade name , with some of the most memorable and distinctive prospect in the moving-picture show being consigned to after the credit have rolled . Marvel even troll their own buff in the post - credits tantrum ofSpider - Man : Homecoming , when the credits ended to show Captain America delivering a talking to on solitaire and how sometimes things are n’t deserving the wait .
Related : All 32 MCU End - Credits Scenes Explained
As significant as the post - credit scenes may be to the Marvel brand , the world is that many of them prove a little problematic . Even the writers ofAvengers : Infinity Warhave admit they have no approximation what Thanos is doing in the post - credits conniption ofAvengers : Age of Ultron ; where is he and who is he even talking to ? But the real problems , oddly enough , are back in Phase 1 . All these post - credits scene were essentially setup - and as such they do n’t hold up to careful scrutiny .
The MCU Post-Credits Scene Tease Events That Didn’t Happen
The fundamental trouble is that none of the setup in those former post - credits scenery is paid off . They tease events that do n’t quite happen . Take that famed post - credits scene inIron mankind : Tony Stark returns home to retrieve that S.H.I.E.L.D. director Nick Fury has broken in and is waiting for him . rage welcomes Stark to a bigger existence of poor boy , telling him that he ’s not the only superhero in town , and even mention the Avengers Initiative . This is one of the most all-important scenes in the total MCU , explicitly cluing viewers in to the overarching direction of Phase 1 . But it ’s also rather unpaired when catch in light of the rest of the MCU ; for one thing , Fury make it sound as though he ’s already work with a bunch of superheroes , when in reality Tony Stark does n’t get to match any S.H.I.E.L.D. enhance plus at all . And then there ’s the fact Fury countermand Stark ’s engagement in the Avengers Initiative inIron Man 2 .
The post - credits scene ofThe Incredible Hulkis even more problematic , with Stark approaching General Ross and offer to help with his Hulk problem . It clear indicated that the Avengers ' first charge would be hunting down the Hulk , an idea that ’s reverse straight from theUltimatescomics . But the hunt for the Hulk never happen , and in fact Marvel had to shoot an entire one - shot to get this ; according toThe Consultant , S.H.I.E.L.D. sent Stark as a sucker , knowing he ’d irritate General Ross to the point he refused to get together with them . It was a smart fix , but it for sure underscores the fact this had n’t been thought through quite as much as casual viewers imagine . Moving on , Fury recruits Dr. Selvig to try out upon the Tesseract in the post - credits scenery ofThor , with a cool scene revealing that Selvig is under Loki ’s control condition . But that plot - point is completely degenerate inThe Avengers , with Loki using the Scepter to take control of Selvig ’s mind just as he does Hawkeye ’s . And the post - credits scene ofCaptain America : The First Avengeris basically just a trailer forThe Avengers .
Even the post - credits scene ofThe Avengersdoesn’t really work . It sees the Other report in to Thanos , revealing that the Mad Titan was the one who is truly behind the Chitauri encroachment of Earth . " They are unruly , " the Other notes of humanity , " and therefore can not be ruled . " That comment implies that the goal of the Chitauri encroachment was a unproblematic conquest , with the Chitauri then aiming to rule the ashes of the Earth . Then , crucially , the Other continues ; " To dispute them is to court demise . " This statement lead Thanos to become and face the screen , with a grinning on his face . Whedon is advert to a comic - book - precise Thanos , one who explicitly want to " royal court Death . " But , of grade , when Marvel finally explored Thanos ' character and motivations inAvengers : Infinity War , they moved out from the comic book version completely .
Related : None Of The Avengers : Infinity War Setup Was Actually compensate Off
Iron Man 2’s Post-Credits Scene Is The Only One That Makes Sense
There ’s just one post - credits scene in the integrality of Phase 1 that make sense;Iron Man 2 ’s . In this picture , Agent Coulson arrives at an wallop site in the New Mexico desert , one that ’s already ring by civilians . As he calls it in , the camera pan out to give away a injection of Mjolnir at the center of the crater . This fussy post - credits scene tie-in in absolutely withThor , where Odin enchants the hammering and casts it through the Bifrost . Scenes inThorshow the civilians attempting to raise it - include a celebrated Stan Lee cameo - before they ’re forced off by S.H.I.E.L.D. agent . Look nearly , and this is really the only Phase 1 post - credits scene that Marvel in reality deliver on .
Page 2 of 2:Why The Post-Credits Scenes Don’t Make Sense
Why MCU Phase 1’s Post-Credits Scenes Don’t Make Story Sense
Over the age , Marvel has developed a reputation for play the long secret plan - and , for the most part , it ’s well - pull in . But in the other day of the MCU , Marvel did n’t get laid for sure where thing were going to go . Take the good example of theIron Manpost - credits tantrum , which essentially lay the foundations for the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe ; not only was it not even part of the original script , theater director Jon Favreau has admitted it was in the beginning " a turn of a titlark " sum up as an Easter egg for fans . Meanwhile , Kevin Feige himself has accept that the post - credits scene ofThe Incredible Hulknever paid off ; " We do not survey up on that scene in the narrative in any of the subsequent feature , " he toldIndieWire , and take note thatThe Consultantone - shot was intended to join the dots and help Marvel get out of the nook it had boxed itself into . And the post - credits shot ofThe Avengers , which introduce Thanos , was added at Joss Whedon ’s request because he wish the scoundrel ; howeverhe had absolutely no idea what to do with Thanosafterwards . " I kind of hung [ Thanos ] out to dry , " Whedon observed in a recent consultation .
The post - credits scene ofIron Man 2is dissimilar , though . Thorwas already in yield , meaning it could in reality be filmed on exercise set . What ’s more , Marvel take to take the strange dance step of having the post - credits scene be shoot byThor ’s director , Kenneth Branagh . As a termination , Branagh even shoot it with special anamorphic Lens to twin his film . It was a much better approach , resulting in a stiff story link between the post - credits aspect and the succeeding movie , and it ’s become Marvel ’s standard operating function through phase 2 and 3 .
Related : How The Thor Movies in secret precede The Multiverse To The MCU
Why MCU Phase 1’s Post-Credits Scenes Are Still Good
As established , then , the post - credits scenes do n’t really make in term of the MCU ’s overall narration ; but that does n’t of necessity mean that they ’re bad . In truth , they ’re still staggeringly exciting , and they serve their purpose in the overarching story of the MCU . Those use were :
Five out of six post - credit scenes live up to their use without any real issue at all . Each serves as a bridgework from the current film to the futurity , albeit a very loose one ; and they do that admirably well . Meanwhile , Marvel has learn from the full of these -Iron Man 2 ’s - and that approach has become fairly much standard in the innovative MCU .
More:Avengers: Endgame Would’ve Been Different With Marvel’s 2014 Phase 3 Plan
