Avengers: Endgame
Avengers 4is all but confirmed to be a fourth dimension travel pic . While this mean the MCU is n’t resting on its honour after the spectacularcliffhanger terminate ofAvengers : Infinity War , there is the lingering gumption that whatever method of clock time locomotion is used wo n’t act in Marvel ’s already notoriously break up timeline .
The MCU has flirted with time travel in the past tense - most unforgettably using the Time Stone in the last act ofDoctor Strangeto trap Dormammu and as a final step in Thanos ' plan to recover the Mind Stone from Vision - butAvengers 4looks coiffure to spoil the TARDIS ' doors off . Set photos indicate recreation of previous movies with multiple versions of graphic symbol and new additions - include the Battle of New York with Ant - Man and two Tony Starks - as well as a shared carpus equipment that seems to power it . It ’s been summons that there are parallels to the famously - windingLost , and multipletime travelling methodshave already appear in the movies .
Related:Avengers 4: Time Travel Movie Explained
But if this is genuine ( which it almost certainly is ) , there is drive for concern . Marvel ’s hit rate is staggering , but if there ’s one area they ’ve always struggled with , it ’s era - spanning persistence . That ’s not to sayAvengers 4could be undone by a perverted story , but it ’s central plot of land gadget may not be as graceful as some are hoping .
Very Few Time Travel Movies Make Sense
The overriding job with clip travel is that it ’s not material , take a crap it heavy to lay out in any word form of media . In the simple damage , prison term moves linearly , and while it is technically potential to move forrad in fourth dimension quicker than others , creating the illusion of travel onward ( this is essentially what happens in the firstPlanet of the Apes ) , right traversal will destroy anything with spate , rent alone a live thing . Without anything to go off , writer must build metre travel mechanics from the ground up . And , unfortunately , very few movies have extremely fix rules that they then stick around to .
In terms of positive , The Terminatoris probably the best example ( if you vex to the James Cameron duology ) . The first moving-picture show does n’t actually change the past but rather counters that with a simple sentence loop - Skynet institutionalize a T-800 to kill Sarah Connor before she conceives John Connor , but protector Kyle Reese is really John ’s father - and whileTerminator 2 : Judgement Daydoes purpose to change things , it pretend sense standing by itself . Also noteworthy arePrimer , which is more logic recitation than movie , andLooper , which has ridiculous rules yet does follow them to a tee .
Related:Best Time Travel Movies Of All Times
Page 2 of 2:Why Marvel’s Time Travel Is Destined To Confuse
Marvel’s Timeline Is Broken Anyway
Before going into the clip travel pitfalls , it ’s first deserving note that theMarvel timelinewe’re dealing with is rather complicated . The share continuity has been a key selling point for the MCU , allowing movies to effortlessly cross - promote and a encompassing supporting players to be called upon at any here and now , but in terms of coherence , it ’s usually only in a macro and character sense . you could place the films in monastic order , graph the heroes ' electric arc , and big event will be advert in various films , but if you dig up deep into throwaway references and Easter Eggs , things do n’t line up anywhere virtually as well . The MCU is so big that its micro continuity just ca n’t work .
The most gross example has to beSpider - Man : Homecoming , which declare itself as seteight age after The Avengers , despite all in - population logic suggesting it was only four years on . This was eventually reversed byAvengers : Infinity War , which through cautiously post lines of dialogue essentially retconned the " eight age " schoolbook carte du jour , but even with the jam you have a very unclear timeline .
Related:Avengers: Infinity War Corrects Marvel’s Broken Timeline
Indeed , in the nine months betweenSpider - gentleman’s gentleman : HomecomingandAvengers : Infinity War , there were plenteous sports fan solution provided that highlighted further inconsistencies , as well as two subsequent releases -Thor : RagnarokandBlack Panther- which altered effect of late films in their own , piffling mode . The MCU timeline works for the purposes of making new film with a shared history ; like the previously discussed movies , they succeed in their primary purpose . It does not , though , if you ’re going to work back through it with any good sense of eubstance .
That make time travel immediately complicated - how do you balance out which events find in what way ? - but is made all the trickier when you in reality dig out into potential mechanics .
Avengers 4 Is Destined To Confuse
Avengers 4appears to be going for the rewrite access , with the hold up heroes working their path back through clock time in a bid to take the Infinity Stones before Thanos ever receive his gold hand on them . We already get laid from set pic this involves alternate versions of events like Ant - Man at the Battle of New York , meaning disregardless of eventual achiever , metre is rewritten in some minuscule way ; an impact must be felt . Add that we have two unlike methods of time traveling - the Time Stone and theQuantum Realm- and it ’s all a snatch unwieldy .
It ’s definitely possible that Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely have done the impossible here and managed to introduce , develop and maintain mechanism that are coherent throughout the film and leave the MCU still working forward comeAvengers 4 ’s end . Again , this wo n’t be the ultimate marking of the film ’s success -Avengers : Infinity Warshouldered comparable logic leaps - but definitely be will something check for as the story extend . However , even if they do make it hold up to examination , that ’s no guarantee the flick will be understood .
Related:Avengers 4 Theory: How Thanos Already Knew About Tony Stark
And that is the real barrier to score a logical meter locomotion movie ; not only do other films tend to combine unlike methods , but so do interview . You need only look at the like ofLostandHarry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkabanto see this in military action ; both had clearly - defined and strictly follow method of time traveling - " whatever encounter , fall out " , with character able to spring to the past but unequal to of altering anything - yet fans to - this - day question why being a part of Dharma did n’t change the nowadays or why Harry did n’t just kill Voldemort in the trot . None of the confusion really comes from the media itself , but an hearing engender on time travel confusion . slight wonderDeadpool 2didn’t even attempt to make sense of Cable ’s watch .
For something with as bountiful and wide-ranging a fandom as the MCU , this will inevitably be reprize . Time traveling is inherently confusing and there ’s nothing aboutAvengers 4to intimate it will be any dissimilar . The only tangible way out is to ensure there ’s more at dramatic play than just a journey back to collect the Infinity Stones .
Next:Avengers 4: Every Update You Need To Know
